'Tis the season for braises, slow-cooked meat that falls apart into tender chunks. Here's a new favorite cut of meat for me: The inexpensive, incredibly delicious crosscut beef shank.
The crosscut beef shank is basically just what it sounds (and looks) like: A crosscut piece of the animal's leg. It's full of tendons and muscle, and a chunk of bone. It doesn't look very pretty, and if you tried to cook it fast, it would be tough and hard to chew.
But if you cook this meat low and slow, the marrow in that bone melts out, helping create a smooth, rich sauce, and the meat itself gets melting and tender.
Here I match the robust taste of this beefy cut with an entire bottle of red wine (this, people, is what Trader Joe's Two Buck Chuck is made for), a lot of beef broth, and a bit of balsamic vinegar for acidity. I also add a heaping dose of black pepper, which wakes up the dish. It isn't terribly spicy, but that black pepper is very assertive, matching the beef in intensity. Beef needs this kind of treatment, sometimes; it can be overwhelmingly rich and sweet. Here the acidity of the vinegar and the punch of pepper balance that out for a more well-rounded dish.
This dish also illustrates my philosophy on slow cookers: The slow cooker is not always there to save you work. If you threw the meat into the slow cooker with these ingredients, without building some flavor in the skillet first, you would miss out on a lot of flavor and depth. It's important to do a little up-front work, but then of course you can walk away from it all day (or all night), let the slow cooker do the hard work of melting the meat into something delicious, and come back to a meal all ready to be devoured.

Slow Cooker Peppered Beef Shank in Red Wine
serves 4 to 6 as a main course
2 to 2 1/2 pounds beef crosscut shank, fat trimmed away
Kosher salt and freshly ground black pepper
Vegetable or peanut oil
10 to 12 cloves garlic, peeled and roughly chopped
2 medium yellow onions, peeled and roughly chopped
1 large stalk celery, roughly chopped
1 bay leaf
1 rosemary sprig
750 ml bottle inexpensive red wine, such as Charles Shaw Cabernet Sauvignon
4 cups beef broth
2 tablespoons balsamic vinegar
Heat a wide, deep skillet over medium high heat. Pat the beef shanks dry and season generously with salt and pepper. Add a drizzle of oil to the pan, and when it hot, add the beef shank. Sear the meat for at least 7 minutes on each side, creating a dark brown crust. When the meat has been thoroughly browned, remove from the pan and place in a slow cooker insert.
Turn the heat down to medium and add the garlic, onion, and celery. Cook for about 15 minutes, stirring occasionally, letting the onion acquire some browning and color. Add the bay leaf and the rosemary sprig, and pour in the red wine and broth. Add 1/2 tablespoon ground black pepper. Bring to a boil, then lower the heat and simmer for about 20 minutes. The liquid should reduce by about 1/3. (Check out this brilliant tip for checking to see how far a sauce has reduced.)
Pour the sauce and vegetables over the meat in the slow cooker. Stir in the balsamic vinegar. Cover and cook for 6 to 8 hours on LOW. You will know the meat is done when it is extremely tender and has fallen away from the bone and into small pieces.
If you do not wish to serve it right away, refrigerate. This also makes it easier to remove the excess fat. Spoon out any chilled shards of fat after the shanks have been refrigerated for several hours. To serve, heat gently in its sauce in a Dutch oven or saucepan on the stovetop. Taste and if necessary add additional salt.
Serve over polenta or pasta.

Related: Friday Night Slow-Cooked Brisket and Onions
(Image: Faith Durand)



Elizabeth Apron fro...

I am dying to try this! Now where to find beef shanks in Sacramento. . . .
I bought some HUGE, meaty beef shanks on my way home from work tonight and will be starting them up using this recipe tomorrow morning.
Oooh. This looks like a good cut to ask the butcher about....
Could you make this with a different cut of meat?
Anybody have any idea how you would modify this for a Dutch Oven?
After 3.5 hours, my crock pot on low is simmering at 208*. A low oven (250 or less) would probably accomplish similar temps with a dutch oven.
OMG that looks incredible!
I'd imagine that you could use any stewing cut of beef. Chuck, short ribs, even brisket would work really well.
After cooking, I thought the sauce was still a bit thin, sooooo.... I took the shank pieces out of the slow cooker and cleaned them up.
I added the liquid and veggies (removing the rosemary stem and bay leaf) to a 10" skillet and whizzed it with my immersion blender. I simmered it a bit to reduce and then added the meat back it. I served this with some fresh rolls.
Then, it was awesome. Thanks for the great start. =D
@ArtoriusRex that sounds fantastic. My slow cooker actually lets out quite a lot of steam as it cooks (the lid doesn't fit tightly at all) so my sauce reduced really too much.
@rdhwyalane the sauce would work well over any beef, but I would especially suggest short ribs or a different cut of beef shank.
@elishagrow yep, I agree with all the comments. To make this in a Dutch oven, I would bake it covered in the oven at about 250 or 300 for at least 4 hours. (It will probably be done a little faster than in the crock-pot.)
I thought the sauce was a little too thin, too. But I just lived with it. I will definitely make this again! Btw, I served it with these stackers: http://www.thekitchn.com/thekitchn/makeahead-vegetarian-recipe-beet-sweet-potato-stacks-160476?image_id=3005294
and some of the extra greens and it was amazing!!!
This is in the crockpot right now - can't wait to taste it and see how it turns out!
@slacker70 Maybe your handle is the giveaway, but beef shanks are very easy to find. I too live in Sacramento, and use them often in broths and soups, as well as similar braises to this one. If you have money, try Whole Foods or Nugget, ask if you do not see them out right. If you are not rich (like me) try a local Asian grocer (I have a Korean supermarket near me that sells beef shanks @ $3/lb.) or Mexican grocer. If you do not know of one near you, I know there are many of both kinds located on Stockton Boulevard. Good luck.
Do you think it would still be good if I did everything before putting in the slow cooker at night, put it in the fridge, and then dumped everything in the slow cooker in the morning so it could cook all day? I don't personally see any issues, but I'm new to a slow cooker!
Anyone have a favorite store-bought beef broth they recommend? I have yet to find one that I love. I don't use it often, so making my own just doesn't make sense.
Question for all who have already made this dish - would it still be good if you omitted the garlic? Garlic makes me very very sick and I am usually able to leave it out of recipes with no problem, but when the recipe calls for '12 cloves' I get concerned that the dish would be very bland if it is made without - thoughts?
Wholefood market the best place in Las Vegas for beef shank. And, unbelievably for Wholefoods, not expensive. I have 2 shanks in the freezer. Soon to be tried with this recipe.
I made this yesterday and it was amazing. I couldn't find some cross-cut beef shanks but I did find deboned shanks at my Korean grocer that worked nicely. I also thought the sauce was a little thin, so I pulled out some of the broth (which I am now saving for what I expect to be an amazing french onion soup) and added some corn starch to thicken (my slow cooker insert is stove and oven safe, I love it for instances like this). I had doubled the recipe because I was feeding a larger group and it just barely fit in my 5.5 qt slow cooker; I ended up cooking it for a total of about 10 hrs on low. I also tossed in some peas at the end because the monochrome nature of the dish was killing me. :)
I cooked this recipe in two nights. The first night I sewers it, made the sauce and cooked for about an hour. The next night I cooked it for 4 hrs. It was delicious! I had it in mind to parter it up with smashy tapatos (mashed patatos) and I am glad I did. The sauce had such rich flavors. I put in fresh rosemary, yum! I left out the celery. Next time maybe I will add it but does it alter the flavor much?
I stopped by a Mexican butcher and once I figured out how to ask for the cut in Spanish, he pulled two for me--$2.50 a pound!
I had done everything as was told in the recipe. I just had planned to use a Romertopf (clay vessel). So, did everything as in recipe, then cooked on high at 375 for an hour, then 325 for 3 hours. It fell off the bone and was A HIT for our party! Fabulous, fabulous, fabulous!! Highly recommend this recipe!!