• $18.81 for 3 jars
I picked up a jar of this chocolate peanut butter a week and a half ago on a whim, just to see what it was like. Well, it's just about gone already. My husband and I both appreciated how it walked the line - neither too chocolate-y, but with just enough cocoa to make it just a bit special. This isn't dessert, but it is lightly sweetened, and it's totally delicious on morning toast. Shown here from Amazon, but also available in grocery stores for about $6 a jar.