It's been exactly two years since I wrote about my favorite cherry custard tart recipe and I still stand by it. There isn't a soul on earth who has tasted it and hasn't promptly fallen in love. But with so many cherries in the Bay Area markets right now, it was time to think Beyond the Tart. Roasted cherries sounded intriguing, so I gave them a try over the weekend. I am pleased to report that I now can stand by two cherry recipes! Read on for the recipe.
This recipe is based on one from The Big Sur Bakery Cookbook with some notable changes. First, I used demerara sugar, which added smoky caramel notes, and less of it (two tablespoons instead of three.) I also swapped their recommended sweet dessert wine (Banyuls Rimage, which I didn't have on hand) with some homemade cherry brandy. The cherries are roasted whole but can be pitted before serving, which is recommended if you are feeding those too young or too old to deal with the pits. (Don't pit them beforehand, or you'll release too many juices.)
The cherries come out of the oven plump and almost black, with rich, spicy notes from the sugar and brandy. Roasting intensifies the cherry flavor and concentrates the texture, making the cherries almost chewy. The sugar and juices produce a thick, absolutely delicious sauce.
I served these cherries over vanilla ice cream, going the simple route in order to get a good sense of their flavor and texture. You could also spoon them over a custard or flan, or pound or sponge cake, or yogurt, or a mild goat cheese.
Roasted Cherries
24 large, plump and very ripe cherries
2 tablespoons demerara sugar
Pinch sea salt
A few grinds of fresh pepper
1/4 cup cherry brandy (or Banyuls Rimage wine, if you have such things lying about)
Preheat oven to 450°. Place the whole cherries in a small roasting pan (I used a pie plate) and sprinkle on the sugar, salt and pepper. Place in the oven and roast until the cherries start to release their juices and the sugar melts and begins to caramelize. This will take about 10 minutes but watch the cherries very carefully, as the sugar may start to burn.
Remove from the oven, pour the brandy over and return for another 5 minutes and roast until the juices start to bubble up. Remove from the oven and let cool slightly before serving. Can be cooled completely and reheated gently on the stove top. (If you're removing the pits, do this before reheating.)
Related: Small-Batch Canning: Making Cherry Preserves
(Image: Dana Velden)

Comments (10)
Can you make this with regular brown sugar? Also, how about any substitutes for cherry brandy - that isn't something I'd have lying around but this sounds amazing.
Hi Mandy:
I've only made this as listed in the recipe above, so I don't know for sure what would work. But I do know the recipe seems forgiving and open to interpretation. For example, I wonder if amaretto or other almond-flavored liquor would be good for those who like cherry-almond.
I'm sure regular brown sugar would be fine or even white sugar (the original recipe just said sugar.) I would imagine any sweet dessert wine would do, or you could experiment with red wine or a non-cherry brandy. Rum might be interesting, too.
I would have never thought of roasting cherries, but this sounds so intriguing. I can imagine that it would intensify and deepen the flavor much like roasting vegetables does. There are loads of cherries in the stores around here right now, so it's the perfect time to grab a few and give this a try.
I just went cherry picking and we went way overboard. I've made tarts and clofutis up the yenyang. This sounds wonderful, I'll have to give it a try.
side note - I'll be making that cherry custard tart soon too :)
This sounds delicious and so very easy and not just to be used in deserts; a little spooned over some pork loin or chicken breasts is what I have in mind.
I usually have an unopened bottle of port in the house so I'll use that as the alcohol choice.
This looks interesting. From the pics it appears that bing cherries are used. I think I may try this w the tart Door County, Wi cherries we will get later this summer.
On a semi-related note, I've been making that custard the last couple weeks and have got to say how wonderful that recipe is! It has been a real hit and is pretty easy to make. I even bought a larger tart pan to make it (but if you only have the 9" pan I had, you can make a mini version — I used a Fiesta mini pie baker. Thank you!
Making some now, but adding Canton and Brandy. Smells good in here.
The best Cherries I ever ate!
I made with around 60 cherries so had it a little longer in the oven 20 min at 200 degrees Celsius. And 10 minutes later with the cherry brandy.
The remaining juice with a salty aftertaste is just KILLER!!!
I used 'Fleur de sel'... it also makes a difference I guess.
I'm definitely going to make some more and keep it in the fridge for special occasions!!!
Congratulations on the recipe....so easy and quick o do and SO TASTEFUL!
So glad to find this recipe - I was thinking of roasting cherries with red onions and sprinkling them with balsamic vinegar and thyme for a side dish and then mixed with barley for leftovers. I love Spring and Summer!
Thanks for the temps and times and wish me luck!