Pot roast may be the definitive braised weekend dish, its rich beefy smell bringing back Sunday family suppers and autumn evenings. I love the meaty taste of pot roast just falling to pieces in its braising liquid, but I don't always have a whole weekend day to devote to the slow, careful cooking that a big roast needs to become tender. So here's a twist on the usual oversized pot roast: Individual-sized pieces of beef that cook much more quickly, but still have that melting, slow-cooked quality.
This is a 2-hour meal, no more — a very reasonable amount of time for a weekday supper, especially if you want to bustle around and get a few things done around the house while it cooks. It even comes with its own vegetable: Snappy carrots, cooked until tender but still bright, perked up with fresh thyme and black pepper.
There are several reasons, actually, that I like this recipe just as much as a classic brisket or pot roast. There's the aforementioned time advantage — you can get home from work at 5:30, put this in the oven, and still eat dinner at a reasonable hour. (And if 2 hours is too long a timeframe for preparing dinner, this, like most braised meats, is a very good make-ahead meal — it's equally as delicious when warmed up at a later time.)
But I also enjoy this recipe for its presentation. It can be a casual supper for an evening in, but it also makes a great dish for a weekend dinner party. Instead of hacking and shredding a bigger roast to pieces, you can present each guest with a plateful of carrots and sauce, topped with their own piece of meat. It's like a homier autumn answer to a filet mignon.
And finally, this recipe offers loads of flavor. So much of the flavor in braised meat comes from the browning step. I like to brown meat quite dark, and since this recipe has you cut the pot roast into separate pieces, this offers even more surface for that brown crust of flavor. So each modest piece of beef comes with an extra helping of delicious taste and tender meat.
I like to serve this quite simply with just the carrots, making it a true one-pot meal. The carrots get tender but not mushy; I like mine with just the faintest bit of snap still left inside. But of course you can ladle the meat and its sauce over pasta or rice (I don't bother making gravy — the braising liquid of tomatoes and red wine has plenty to offer without going that extra step).

Individual Pot Roasts with Thyme-Glazed Carrots
Serves 41 1/2 to 2 pounds chuck roast
Salt and freshly ground black pepper
Olive oil
1 large onion, diced
5 cloves garlic, smashed and roughly chopped
1 1/2 cups red wine, such as Malbec
1 15-ounce can diced tomatoes, with their juices
1 whole sprig fresh rosemary
2 whole sprigs fresh thyme
1 tablespoon unsalted butter
2 tablespoons fresh thyme leaves
1 16-ounce bag baby carrots
Heat oven to 325°F. Quarter the chuck roast into 4 equally-sized chunks of meat, like mini pot roasts. Sprinkle lightly with salt and pepper.
Heat a heavy deep pan or Dutch oven over high heat. When the pan is hot, place each piece of the chuck roast in the pan. Sear for several minutes (or until the the meat releases easily) on both sides. You may need to do this in two batches; don't crowd the pan. Let the meat get quite dark, with crusty spots on both sides.
When the meat is well-browned, remove it from the pan and put on a plate. Drizzle a little olive oil into the pan and turn the heat down to medium. Add the onions and garlic, and sprinkle lightly with salt. Cook the onions and garlic for about 5 minutes, stirring until they are soft. Add the wine and scrape any remaining bits of meat up from the bottom of the pan. Pour in the tomatoes and bring the mix to a simmer, then turn off the heat.
Add the meat back into the pan. Place the rosemary sprig and whole thyme sprigs in the pot. Cover with a tight-fitting lid and put in the oven. Cook for 1 1/2 hours, or until the meat is very tender.
In the last 30 minutes of cooking, heat a heavy saucepan over medium heat and add the butter. Melt, then add the thyme leaves and carrots. Cook, stirring, until the carrots are glazed with the thyme. Season generously with salt and pepper. Add to the pot roast in the oven and cover. Leave the carrots in the pot for the last 30 minutes of cooking the pot roasts (or until tender).
Remove from the oven and let rest for 10 to 15 minutes. Then serve with the carrots on the side, and with pasta or good bread, if desired.
On this recipe in the slow cooker:
I haven't tested this in the slow cooker, and overall I prefer the oven to the slow cooker these days. This especially applies to beef. My slow cooker refuses, even on LOW, to go below a steady boil, which I think is too much heat for beef. I often find my brisket or pot roast stringy and tough out of the slow cooker. You may have better success of course, but I think this is so quick in the oven it's probably not the best recipe to throw in the slow cooker anyway.

Related: How To Roast a Chicken
(Images: Faith Durand)
Kart Serving Tray b...

Comments (45)
So, stew?
No - they still turn out in mini pot-roast-size chunks, which makes them really nice for serving. Plop each one in a bowl with some pasta or rice, pour over the broth and don't worry about cutting up one big hunk of meat.
You start on top of the stove and then finish it in the oven, right? So the 2 1/2-3 hours is done in the oven at 300 degrees?
C.
No, sorry, 2 hours to cook is not a weeknight meal. At least not if you have children and/or don't get home until after 6.
Love your site. Just a question on your comment about your slow cooker not going low, below a steady boil.
Do you feel all slow cookers inherently have this problem or simply less expensive models?
Stillyszy, I'm not sure. Mine is a slightly higher-end model, actually -- it's newish (last 5 years). I heard once that newer slow cookers run hotter, for safety reasons, but I have never verified that.
Yum...I'm in!
We can't use wine in our cooking. Advice for this recipe?
We always used oven bags for all of our pot roasts and roasted birds (even Thanksgiving turkey) when I was growing up. I didn't even realize that most people don't use them until I moved out on my own. They cut the cooking time significantly as well.
ekathrein, beef or chicken stock would also do nicely, with a splash of balsamic vinegar at the end to add some more flavor.
I've used beef broth + balsamic vinegar (or red wine vinegar) to sub for wine when I don't have any.
This is making me so hungry! Yum!
This is a really good idea - I almost never think of cutting things into portion sizes before braising. Although, I only wish I could get home by 5:30... more like 6:30-7pm with kids to feed before bed, so this will still have to wait for the weekend. My sister swears by her pressure cooker after living in Morocco for years... I should just bite the bullet and go get one. I bet this would turn out great in there (probably adding the carrots after a bit).
Is it easy to find chuck roasts in the 1-2 lb range?
to the reader who said two hours isn't practical. I have two young children and often can't start dinner until 6:00 pm. I refuse to go the chicken nugget in the toaster oven route on a regular basis because I believe this will establish poor eating habits in my children later on. I often make an extra dinner, usually a pot roast on Sunday night and then simply re-heat it on Monday. Pot roast always tastes better the second day anyway. It makes the world of difference to have at least one meal prepared in advance during the work week.
@sygyzy the place I buy meat usually has them around that size, but you can always ask the butcher -- even at a mainstream grocery store -- to cut a piece down for you. Or use half and freeze the other.
@keltrue, yes! I have some pressure cooker content all lined up for early in the winter! Really excited to talk about it here.
Your recipe sounds like a "simplified" Sauerbraten..... I'd like to try it on a weekday night!
http://7th-taste.com/2012/04/10/amish-sauerbraten/ Sauerbraten tastes great, but it takes a long time to make it..... realistically it's just for Sunday night special family meal..... not for everyday cooking.....
Mine, Crock-Pot brand, does not have this problem. I can set it to high, low, or auto--it starts high and self switches to low.
Faster cooking or not, cutting the roast into individual servings before cooking is a great idea, Faith. It lets the braising liquids get at more of the meat's surface—and it makes the individual servings look more like that instead of shared chunks or slices. Brilliant!
I used to make beef, pork and chicken stew/pot roast/etc. on the weekend. They all improve with age and make it easier to feed the family healthfully after a long day at work. Clam or fish chowder can be saved up to 2 days; you cannot freeze chowder owing to all the milk, but you can freeze the base made ahead up to the point of adding milk.
Now a retired widow living alone, I cook fresh every day.
For a change from beef or chicken with carrots, try pork with cabbage and Granny Smith apples simmered in beer. Use juniper berries and/or fennel seeds along with the more usual spices.
A nice change with chicken is Asan vegs, simmer with curry paste (or powder, but paste is better--try green curry paste) then thaw and add and heat coconut milk just before serving.
Sorry, must agree with Latenac. But I will try this recipe on the weekend, sounds great.
Any thoughts on venison? I have a roast that I really need to cook, and if I could use this recipe I would be more apt to do it sooner! More time on the meat u think?
This recipe sounds delicious and I like the technique but the bag of baby carrots is really quite depressing. Real carrots taste good. Baby carrots are a processed product with depressing flavor. Also, they've managed to make your homemade pot roast look like something from Hormel.
Regarding newer crock pots: they definitely run hotter than older models even when set to low. There have been a number of threads on this issue on several foodie sites because it has really affected the outcomes of formerly reliable well-loved recipes. I have a 4 yr old All-Clad crock pot and I do love it but it definitely runs hotter than my old Rival from 25 yrs ago so I have to adjust for that as best I can. PS - I will definitely try this recipe - my standard pot roast recipe is done in the oven and is delicious but requires I flip the meat every 30 minutes for 4 hrs. This might be an alternative for those times I can't be there for half a day cooking. Thanks for sharing!
@JudiAU well, ahem! I don't quite know what to say to that! You're of course free to use any carrots you like! I like that they are still totally 100% vegetable (organic here too) and already uniform in size. For getting a quick(er) meal on the table I think they can be a helpful shortcut. But of course do as you like. As long as the carrots are cut to the same size, any sort can be used. Or, for that matter, potatoes, sweet potatoes, squash, or another root vegetable. I just like having the fresh taste and color of carrots here.
And, nice segue - we have an interesting piece on that very topic ("baby" carrots) coming up soon - stay tuned.
The only thing missing are the wedged potatoes. That's my favorite part of a slow-cooked pot roast. Keep the carrots, I want the taters.
I would gently suggest that baby carrots are lacking the sweet flavor of a really good carrot, and that roughly chopping some whole carrots might not take much longer, and the end result will be nicer. It's been my experience that baby carrots are bitter and have a stringy texture.
Do you think this will work with a bottom round or rump roast?
Hum...I pretty much love all your recipes but I just can't get behind this one, sorry. 'Course after that [ahem] comment above, I'm a bit hesitant to share why. I toss this in the slow cooker all at once - often the night before, takes 5 min - & cook it low & slow. Dinner's ready when I walk in the door at 6 pm. I cook this dish fairly often and have never once had to hack or shred the roast. Your presentation is lovely but I could accomplish that by separating the roast with a fork before plating. It is truly that tender. (and yes, confounded, i gotta add taters! lol) Two hours on a weeknight just ain't gonna happen at my house. And, truthfully, it ain't gonna happen on the weekend either for a roast, dinner party or no.
I do agree that a steady boil is too much heat for beef. A slow cooker without a true low setting is NOT a slow cooker in my book. I would be returning it, myself. I've read about 'the mysterious slow cooker phenomena' a few times but never experienced it. I have both old & new slow cookers which I use interchangeably for many tried & true recipes, always with the same result. In fact, on several occasions when cooking for large family get-togethers, I've had this basic recipe going in both, side by side, simultaneously. Both turned out perfectly each time. (haha...kinda makes me wanna run out & buy up all the slow cookers at the thrift stores just in case this is true...worn out a few in my day, i have).
Oh, one more thing....can I politely say I counted two pots in this 'true one-pot meal'?
@ emmerloo86: this recipe should work quite well. Veteran venison cooker here and this is truly a wonderful recipe.
Do you think this would freeze well? Otherwise, I might need a smaller pot to make it a dinner for two.
Definitely not a weeknight meal!! But, sounds yummy for weekend.
I was wondering if I could not use my oven and instead just let it stew on low heat in my dutch oven. I have a small oven oven and a relatively cheap one at that, and I don't really want to put my fancy-ass dutch oven in there... Or is that just me? Coming from Belgium, I've never heard of putting your pots 'n pans inside an oven.
Sounds veeeery tasty though, so I really want to try it!
Although, I could see how this could be made ahead with the last 30 minutes cooking the carrots with the already cooked beef. Maybe make it the night before and pop it in the fridge and continue the next night when you get home. The worse you could get it more flavor!
At least, that's how I do my hearty stick-to-your ribs week night dinners (for hubby and kid). I work and don't get home until 6:30ish.
I use my pressure cooker (mine is 25 yrs old!), and the pot roast is done in 40 min (5 min prep, 5 min browning in frying pan and 30 min in the cooker). The veggies get to be mushy, so I stick with real large carrots.Sometimes I don't even peel them, just wash and chop in large pieces. I buy large pieces of meat and freeze the raw meat in portions. Dividing the meat in serving sizes before cooking it will make it cook faster, just don't cube the meat as for stew.
Looking forward to the pressure cooker recipes! (I also use the cooker for pork roasts).
Made the recipe 2 nights ago...it felt like a Pot Roast kind of day (in Pacific Northwest) and I was so excited. Overall, it was a success with my husband and son (7)...for me however, I grew up with more of a brown sauce type pot roast...this was more like beef burgundy-ish, the red wine and tomatoes were very present. It was more tangy rather than "comfort" - thats the best I can describe. It was good, don't get me wrong, and my expectations were purely based on my mom's pot roast. Mine also came out really soupy. Last comment...I usually always buy my meat from a local grocery store here in Portland (New Seasons) or Whole Foods. I exercised poor judgement thinking that since this was "pot roast" and would cook for 2 hours I could get away with not paying a premium for the meat. Bad move....bought the meat from a huge grocery store chain and I think in the end my biggest issue with this dish was the quality of the meat. Lessoned learned, it always, always pays to buy quality meat, especially when it is the star of the dish. And how did I not know baby carrots were processed??
Baby carrots are "processed" by the easter bunnies! Ha, they are regular sized carrots, cut and sculpted to look like little baby carrots. Regular carrots taste better and last longer than their "baby" siblings.
i agree even for someone who works from home and could easily start this early in the evening 3 hours is a bit much for a weeknight meal. Active prep time is low but I still would only attempt it on a really slow/light day. its suppose to snow Sunday, this sounds like a really nice sunday dinner. Might give it a try
For those who can use wine, suggest brewed coffee or tea to hit some of the flowery, herbal notes wine adds.
I made this recipe yesterday with regular carrots instead of baby and it was fabulous. Thanks!!
I made this recipe today...I used consomme as I didn't have any wine around we didn't want to drink! I have large pots of rosemary and thyme, and they really added something to this dish.
I made half of a 4# chuck roast last week like "Mom's" and it was stringy and tough - I used the rest for this recipe and the meat was so tender we couldn't believe it was the same roast!! I made homemade mashed potatoes with it and thickened a little of the broth for gravy. We liked the fact that the meat wasn't "boiled" in texture and appearance, but was still meltingly tender. I have already shared it with my sister.
Thanks.
I have made this at least three times since I first saw this idea. While I don't eat meat, my family has heartily enjoyed it each time, and I have also served it at a dinner party and received compliments from around the table. Last time I had my husband do a good sear on the grill rather than browning it in the pan....yes I sacrificed some brown bits on the bottom to flavor the sauce, but I saved some smoke from my eyes and he was able to get a harder sear than I can reasonably get stovetop. My family preferred it done that way.
I also like to do a mix of parsnips and carrots in the braise. Thanks for a keeper!
Love this! Can't wait to try it.
I realize this post is pretty old now, but I thought I'd chime in, just in case. I tried this recipe and found that 1 and 1/2 hours was not even close to long enough to make the meat tender. I pulled them around the 2 and 1/2 hour mark, and they still could have used some time. Bottom line - I don't think you actually save any time by cutting them into chunks. Other than that, it's a serviceable pot roast recipe.
Re: Baby Carrots in a bag. You don't really want to know how they're processed, and what's that white bloom after a few weeks in the fridge?