Recipe: Pumpkin Spiced Peanut Butter Cups

Recipe: Pumpkin Spiced Peanut Butter Cups

7623e24f449c20c00e8943f6d2d220739fd2325a?w=240&h=240&fit=crop
Emma Christensen
Oct 14, 2014
(Image credit: Alexis Buryk)

These homemade peanut butter cups are pretty much a slam dunk. I mean, could it get any better? They're two-bite chocolate treats with a nugget of creamy pumpkin-spiced peanut butter in the middle. This is Halloween candy for kids, grown-ups, and everyone in between.

(Image credit: Alexis Buryk)

A Special Treat for a Halloween Party

Ariel special-requested these cups for her Spooky Colorful Halloween Party, and reports that they were a major hit. Pumpkin spice wins again! She used these Halloween cupcake papers from Crate & Barrel as the molds, and trimmed down the sides to better show off the candies.

These Halloween-y treats are an easy riff on my basic recipe for Homemade Peanut Butter Cups. I just bumped up the amount of filling to make these extra-gooey and added a dash of pumpkin spice. Because: pumpkin spice.

To make them even more fun for autumn, I gave each peanut butter cup a dollop of pumpkin butter before adding the final coating of chocolate. You can skip this if you like...but I wouldn't.

One note — definitely set aside an afternoon to make these cups. They're not that complicated, but the process of melting the chocolate, letting it set, and so on takes some time. If you're making these for a party, you can make them several days ahead and keep them in an airtight container in a cool part of your house.

Go on! Make yourself a batch. Just be sure to have a few friends nearby so you aren't tempted to eat them all yourself.

(Image credit: Alexis Buryk)
(Image credit: Alexis Buryk)

Pumpkin Spiced Peanut Butter Cups

Makes 22 to 24

3/4 cup peanut butter or other nut butter
1/2 cup powdered sugar
1 teaspoon pumpkin spice mix, plus more to taste
1 pound good-quality dark chocolate or milk chocolate, chopped if purchased as a block
1/2 cup pumpkin butter, optional

For detailed step-by-step instructions with photos: How To Make Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups

Combine the peanut butter, powdered sugar, and pumpkin spice mix in the bowl of a food processor. Pulse 15 to 20 times until the mixture is dry and crumbly. It should hold together in a ball when pressed and feel moldable but no longer creamy; add more powdered sugar if needed. Taste and add more pumpkin spice in 1/2 teaspoon portions to taste.

Transfer the peanut butter filling to a clean bowl, cover, and keep chilled in the refrigerator until ready to use.

Melt 1/3 of the chocolate in a double-boiler or a heat-proof bowl set over a saucepan of simmering water. Let the chocolate stand without stirring until nearly melted, then stir until smooth. Transfer the melted chocolate to your workspace.

While the chocolate is melting, arrange 24 muffin cup liners on a baking sheet. Once the chocolate has melted, use a spoon to scoop up a small amount of chocolate and drizzle it into the cup liners. Use the back of the spoon to gently smooth the chocolate into a thin layer (roughly 1/8-inch thick, but no need to get exact about it!) on the bottom of the cup. Repeat with all the remaining liners.

Let the chocolate set until hardened. If your house is chilly, the first cups will already be setting by the time you finish the last ones. To speed things along, you can place the cups in the fridge for a few minutes. Wait until the chocolate is firm before continuing with the next steps.

While the chocolate is setting, begin preparing the filling. Scoop up 2 teaspoons of filling and shape them into thick disks with your fingers. The disks should be nearly the diameter of the cup with just a little space left around the edge. Once the chocolate has set, place one disk of filling in the middle of each cup. Dollop about a teaspoon of pumpkin butter over the top of each disk.

Melt the remaining chocolate over a double-broiler or in a heat-proof bowl set over a saucepan of simmering water. Let the chocolate stand without stirring until nearly melted, then stir until smooth. Transfer the melted chocolate to your workspace.

Scoop a generous spoonful of chocolate over the peanut butter filling in each cup. Use the back of the spoon to gently spread the chocolate around the filling and smooth the top. The chocolate should completely cover the filling. If the chocolate starts to thicken too much to easily work with, set it back over a double-boiler until pourable again.

Set the tray of peanut butter cups somewhere cool until the chocolate has fully set and the tops are dry, then you can transfer the candies to a container for storage. Remove the paper wrappers before serving.

Recipe Notes

  • Tempering Chocolate: To give your peanut butter cups a glossy top and an extra snap when you bite into them, you can temper the chocolate before assembling the cups. Here's how: How To Temper Chocolate Without a Thermometer.
Created with Sketch.