Maya asked us how to make the fluffy pink strawberry cake she remembers from childhood. The problem with that cake is that it uses Jell-O and boxed cake mix, and now she wants to make it more naturally. Well, this recipe is still a bit of a compromise but oh will it give you that hot pink color and sweet fruity flavor!
Last winter I showed you the wedding cakes I baked for my brother's wedding. These were simple cakes — just a series of 4-layer vanilla and raspberry cakes stacked up dramatically tall with fresh flowers and sparkling sugar for decoration.
The only thing that gave me pause when planning these cakes was my brother's request for a family favorite: raspberry cake. His favorite birthday cake is very similar to the cake Maya remembers: it calls for white cake mix, frozen raspberries, and raspberry Jell-O.
There was no way I using cake mixes for a wedding cake, so I adapted this recipe to be more homemade, and frankly, better-tasting. I was very nervous about how they would turn out, but the real butter, milk, and good flour made such a difference, and the raspberry taste was just like how I remembered.
But yes, the cake does still have the Jell-O for that "authentic" raspberry flavor. The gelatin adds a deep moistness, too. Hey, for a once-a-year treat, I am not going to rule out gelatin, although it is not something I would usually put in a cake!
This cake is very easy, very moist, and a brilliant hot pink. The icing is just as easy and just as pink. If, like Maya, you would prefer a strawberry cake, try using strawberry gelatin and fresh or frozen strawberries instead. One last note: the icing has no gelatin in it, so if you want to really stay all-natural, what about a dark chocolate cake frosted with hot pink raspberry icing?
Hot Pink Raspberry Cake
makes 2 9" round layers
1/2 cup shortening (non-hydrogenated)
1 1/2 cups sugar
3 eggs
2 1/4 cups flour
1 teaspoon salt
3 1/2 teaspoons baking powder
1 1/4 cups milk
1 red raspberry Jell-O packet, regular size (3 oz.)
1/2 10-oz. pkg. frozen red raspberries, slightly thawed
Preheat the oven to 325°F. Grease two 9" round cake pans with butter or baking spray.
Mix the ingredients together in the order they're listed - creaming the softened shortening and sugar first, then adding the eggs, flour, salt, baking powder, and finally the milk, gelatin, and raspberries. Using an electric beater, beat everything together on low for 30 seconds, then high for 3 minutes.
Immediately pour into the prepared pans and bake for 25-30 minutes, or until the tops spring back slightly when pressed.
Let cool on wire racks for at least 15 minutes, then flip each pan over onto the rack and tap gently all over. Lift the pan slightly. If the cake doesn't feel like it's falling out smoothly, lay a slightly damp kitchen towel over the pan and tap again. If necessary, let the cakes cool more. If they have been baked thoroughly, however, they should fall right out of the pans once they've cooled a little and the sides of the cake have shrunk back from the pan.
Cool completely before frosting, otherwise the frosting will melt everywhere.
Hot Pink Raspberry Icing
1 pound confectioner’s sugar
1/2 cup (1 stick) butter, softened
1/2 10-ounce package raspberries
Combine the softened butter, confectioner’s sugar, and reserved half of the raspberries, thawed. Mix together with electric mixer. Spread on cooled cake.
Related: Pink In the Kitchen: Color Inspiration for Cooks
(Images: KD Touch Photography
3-Tier Cake Stand b...

Comments (21)
Wow, now this is a gorgeous cake.
perfect for my upcoming baby shower, i think!
Very pretty way to display cakes and so wonderful to see a wedding with food that has a personal story connected to it!
It's a nice trend that I'm glad to see illustrated at your brother's wedding!
http://danamccauley.wordpress.com/2009/01/19/independent-brides
Gorgeous. I love this look. Screw fondant!
wheee! can't wait to make this!!!
I'm making them into cupcakes!!
We baked one today; however, the cooking time for us was significantly more than 30 minutes.
Tried it for a birthday tonight! Yummy!!!!
Okay, in the final analysis, I found all the seeds rather off-putting; however, my 9 year old can't get over the cool factor of a hot pink cake. For me, it was just meh...and the frosting was a tad sweet for my tastes. I might try it again with strawberries and back down on the sugar.
I agree completely! I made this for my mother and grandmother for Mother's Day and I could tell that I'd regret the amount of sugar included in the recipe. The raspberries I used were pretty tart so that helped but I'd definitely cut down on sugar also next time. The color was absolutely awesome and everyone ewed and awed of the presentation. I used a little bit more rasberries in the icing than suggested here to achieve the exact color I wanted. I might try this next time with lemon added to the cake and zest in the icing.
@ grlwprls - What would happen if you sieved the raspberries first to get rid of the pips? I can't see it would be a problem for the icing, and I'm guessing that by the time you've blended the cake mix for that long after adding the raspberries, they're all mushed up anyway... I wouldn't want pips in my cake either - unless the berries were in whole fruit form - ie frozen raspberries stirred in at the last moment.
just made these tonight - they came out great! i made them into cupcakes in the pampered chef flowered cupcake pan so they came out in the shapes of roses and daisies. i also had enough batter leftover to make one of layer of cake. my only problem is the frosting - i would love to have something that brought out more of the natural tartness of the raspberries instead of being so sugary sweet - any ideas for that?
i made this cake and it was a big ho-hum. i felt it was super heavy and dense due to the gelatin. it also took longer to cook as others had mentioned.
i followed the recipe word for word so i'm not sure how some people's turned out so great.........
I made the cake this past week. I was worried that the frosting was going to be too sweet. But it balanced out nicely once the cake was all put together. It was a hit!
I make this all the time for girl baby showers and it is always a hit. It is just so unusual and beautiful - I agree that it is very moist and dense, but it is one tasty cake. Everyone always wants the recipe.
I just made cupcakes with this recipe. I also thought the seeds in the frosting were a little too much, and it was a little too sweet overall for me, so next time I'm doing a whipped cream topping instead of buttercream. I think I'll add raspberry pulp/juice strained through a sieve into the cream before whipping to give it the right flavor and color. Or if that fails I will do a bright yellow lemon whipped topping.
Also, I might try cutting back on the sugar in the cake batter just a bit because while I liked the flavor of the cakes, they seem to caramelize a bit on the very edges and some were a tiny bit burned.
This may be a silly question to ask but as I do not do much baking with raspberries I would like to know. It calls for slightly thawed raspberries but I have an entire basket of lovely, fresh raspberries that I wanted to use for this recipe. Does the slightly thawed-ness of the berries contribute to the baking science? Or if they're fresh will it work just as well?
I just made these as cupcakes to send with my son to daycare for Valentines Day. I barely had them out of the oven and had to take a taste... awesome!! They didn't sink on me like cupcakes usually do and the raspberry flavor is so good!
Haven't made it to the icing yet, but I think I'll use the mixer to break up the berries and do a rough strain to get some of the seeds out, based on other reviews.
I made these into cupcakes and instead of using the icing it calls for, I used a homemade lemon icing recipe and then garnished with fresh raspberries and a mint leaf. They turned out delicious. The refreshing lemon balances well with the raspberry flavors.
I love how lavish and extravagant they look. Such a feast for the eyes. I wish I had the guts to try it. I think I need to try simpler baking recipes before attempting this one!
I used 2 lb of sugar instead of 1lb. The longer the icing is on the cake the better it becomes. This is sweet and tangy! Melts in your mouth. I had people fighting over the last part of the cake. :)