We first became addicted to this sandwich when it appeared on the deli menu at City Feed and Supply, and quickly adapted it to our own kitchen! With grainy mustard, sharp cheese, and some crunchy apples, this is the perfect sandwich for a light summer meal outdoors.
With a simple sandwich like this, using the best ingredients possible is key. Get yourself a really good cheddar - one that's a bit crumbly and so sharp that you might not think of eating it on its own. A good grainy mustard adds texture and a bit of vinegar bite to contrast the onion jam.
And use the best ciabatta or baguette you can find. You'll thank yourself the second you bite into that crackling, faintly sweet crust!

Farmer's Lunch Sandwich
Makes 4 sandwiches1 loaf crusty baguette or ciabatta
Whole grain mustard
Sharp cheddar cheese
Butter lettuce
2 hard, tart apples like Granny smith or Braeburn, very thinly sliced
2 to 3 tablespoons lemon juice (from one lemon)
Onion-Thyme Jam (or try one of these recipes!)
Slice the baguette into four sections and slice the sections in half length-wise. Spread a little whole grain mustard on both halves.
Smear a layer of onion jam on the bottom half. Toss the apple slices in a little lemon juice, and then add them to the sandwich. Add a few leaves of lettuce and then top with a layer of cheese. Press the sandwich closed.
If not eating right away, wrap the sandwiches in a tight layer of wax paper. Keep them in a cool place — like a picnic hamper! — until you're ready to eat them. They'll be ok left unrefrigerated for several hours.
Related: Good Food with Evan Kleiman: Barbecues and Picnic Side Dishes
(Image: Emma Christensen for the Kitchn)
Colorful Kitchen Bo...

Comments (22)
Of course I see this post while I'm waiting to take my lunch break. That looks just heavenly! I bet that huge jar of fig jam I've got in my fridge would be a good stand-in for the onion jam. Mmm, figs, apples, and sharp cheddar....
http://www.abreadaday.com
this looks like the English pub classic meal, ploughman's lunch, made into a sandwich. good stuff.
For sure the key is good cheese.
http://www.margincomments.blogspot.com
I LOVE this type of sandwich. One of my all time favs.
I think it would be even better on raisin bread.
mmmmm - delish!
My favourite grocery nearby has an amazing selection of cheeses, including a fantastic carmelized onion cheddar imported from England. I bet this sandwich would be yummy with those additions.
Ooo, I do have baby lettuce growing and just bought some good cheese and a baguette... weekend lunches here I come.
A bit of Branston Pickle wouldn't go amiss.
I live down the street from City Feed and crave this sandwich at least several times a week! Thanks for posting the recipe, it's so crisp and perfect for summer.
www.esculent.wordpress.com
I used to live on Spring Park and this sandwich was a weakness of mine! Hopefully I'll be returning to JP and my beloved City Feed soon.
I tried this over the weekend with a couple of different additions. First was simple roast turkey....very nice. Next, was some left over chipotle chicken from the 'chipotle chicken wrap' recipe featured on here a week or so ago. That combo was awesome! Also nice to use any extra apple slices as a substitute for chips.
What Monty Johnson said. Some Branston pickle would complete this picture for me too.
Made this with pumpernickel bread and sauteed onion in place of the jam. Very yummy!
Hmmm, I think the link to the onion jam might be wrong...
yum
ahhh, but you are missing one essential piece of the City Feed Farmer's Lunch -- pickled green tomatoes!
my husband and I love this sandwich so much we had our caterer create a mini-version for our wedding reception... an almost perfect bite!
I agree with PoppyGirl -- is that the correct recipe for onion jam?
I made a variation on this theme last weekend and loved it, but I couldn't figure out the onion jam recipe. Clarification would be much appreciated!
http://www.thekitchn.com/thekitchn/preserved-foods/three-onion-jams-097988
Thanks for pointing out the onion jam confusion! I'm updating the post now.
this looks so delicious. being 5 months pregnant, i am avoiding cold cuts, but my love of sandwiches has not waned. this works perfectly!
I second the comment about the missing pickled green tomatoes. Such an important ingredient!
I made this with the onion/thyme jam thekitchn.com posted previously and it was so delicious. I ate it open faced because I don't like as much bread but, it was really good!