Chocolate cake came up in the comments on Monday's recipe for quick yellow cake, so here, promptly, is a recipe. This must, however, be prefaced by Laurie Colwin's statement on the topic: "Anyone who spends time in the kitchen eventually comes to realize that what she or he is looking for is the perfect chocolate cake."
Everyone has their preferences when it comes to this perfect chocolate cake, and they usually fall somewhere into Colwin's three types: flourless, fudgy, and cocoa.
Some chocolate cakes are completely flourless - quivering mousses of pure cacao. Some are closer to a brownie with a crackly crust. Others, often found in grocery store bakeries, appear to be dry sponge cakes colored brown. The latter put me off chocolate cake for a long time - I'm a fudge girl, myself. But this recipe changed that for me.
This is a cake cake, with a traditional cakey texture - light, spongy, moist. It has a beautiful shiny top, a springy middle, and it is also another easy, one-bowl recipe. And yet it tastes deeply of chocolate, with dark, almost bitter notes that penetrate the whole bite. It isn't "Death by Chocolate;" it isn't a dense fudgy flourless torte; it's a simple yet true chocolate cake, suitable for layering and frosting.
This was originally a Hershey's recipe; it makes sense, I suppose, that they would have perfected a chocolate cake by now.
Dark Chocolate Cake
makes two 9-inch round cakes or three 8-inch round cakes
2 cups white sugar
1 3/4 cups all-purpose flour
3/4 cup cocoa powder
1 1/2 teaspoons baking powder
1 1/2 teaspoons baking soda
1 teaspoon salt
2 eggs
1 cup milk
1/2 cup vegetable oil
2 teaspoons vanilla extract
1 cup boiling water
Heat oven to 350°F. Grease and flour two 9-inch round baking pans, or three 8-inch round baking pans.
Stir together sugar, flour, cocoa, baking powder, baking soda and salt in a large mixer bowl. Add eggs, milk, oil and vanilla; beat on medium speed of mixer for 2 minutes. Mix in boiling water - the batter will be quite thin. Pour batter into prepared pans.
Bake 30 to 35 minutes or until wooden pick inserted in center comes out clean. Cool 10 minutes on a wire rack, then tap the cakes out of the pans. Cool completely before frosting.

Comments (36)
Cooks illustrated from about a year ago has a recipe for a perfect chocolate bundt cake. Put it in a fancy catherdral bundt cake pan and you instantly impress your guests! Plus the wizards at cooks illustrated found the perfect, scientifically proven recipe!
luke- do you have a copy? i would love to try BOTH!
I'll dig it up
faith, you have no idea how happy you have just made me.
i wonder if i can dig up a peanut-butter frosting recipe...?
:)
Ha! You're welcome. Peanut butter frosting is easy - you just make a basic frosting and use peanut butter instead of butter. Basically, plop some peanut butter into a bowl with a little vanilla, milk, and a lot of powdered sugar. Mix with beaters until smooth and adjust pb/milk/sugar as you go to get the consistency and taste you want.
Faith, thanks for this recipe, I'd make it using 3 8-inch cake pans and the peanut butter frosting sound great!
Luke, someone gave me a cathedral bundt pan a couple of months ago, so I'm anxious for your recipe as well!
Faith, thanks for this. Any suggestions on the best coca powder to use? I will be trying it this weekend... with a mocha cream frosting hopefully
Hi all,
I made this recipe tonight with two (what I thought were small) changes: substituting buttermilk for the milk and using a 13x9" pan.
It fell - big time - any ideas as to why?
I did open the oven to check the rest of dinner about 10 minutes into the cooking. I've never had that happen before.
ps--Faith, great recipe. The batter was delicious and despite whatever went wrong with mine, it still looks wonderfully fudgy.
Laura, oh sad! I'm sorry; I hope it was still good! My chief thought is that the oven temp might have dipped too low, especially if you were cooking other dishes in it at the same time. If the temp gets too low the cake will often fall and become rather dense and possibly underbaked.
Thanks, Faith. I bet you're right. No worries, it tastes good and has the best texture I've ever had in a homemade cake.
the cooks illustrated perfect chocolate bundt cake is in their feb 2004 issue. It is Yummy! especcially with some fresh rasberries and tangy whipped cream
The chocolate bundt cake recipe is reprinted in this years cook's illustrated "holiday baking" issue. Do you think the recipe would work as a layer cake?
i wish i had read this last night before baking my son's birthday cake that did NOT rise! and i even went out specially to buy new baking powder. thanks for the future-use recipe :)
A fantastic recipe, but I always used hot brewed coffee in place of the hot water and sour milk or buttermilk in place of regular milk. This gives a deeper chocolate flavor. And I am glad it was mentioned that this is a very thin batter, the sight of it makes a person panic and think something is wrong, but thin (batter) is in!
Just an update comment: I still make this cake a lot; it's a quick, go-to chocolate cake. It's truly never-fail, too, for me...
To Laura: If you substitued buttermilk without also adding some baking soda to compensate chemically, you could have the results you describe. Baking is chemistry! Whenever you make a change, you need to balance it chemically with the other ingredients.
I personally love the Texas Sheet Cake recipe from the Joy of Cooking. It's my go-to recipe for kid birthdays and special events.
I used this as a base for a tres leches cake, and it turned out fanatastic. Thank you for posting that, it's a great recipe!
I just want to thank you for sharing this recipe. I was searching for a special cake to make and this sounded good...it's still too early for summer fruit. Two amazing things about this recipe to me. First, it worked at high altitude without any alterations. We live at 6800 feet and I have not baked a cake (successfully) for the entire 12 years we have lived here. I'm really psyched to have a go-to cake recipe! Second, this reminds me so much of the Hand-Me-Down chocolate cake recipe from my 1970s childhood....does anyone remember that?
This cake is fantastic. I loved the color; almost purple, almost black. I doubled it, paired it with chocolate cream cheese frosting between layers, and a thick fudge outer coat, for my baby sister's 15th birthday. Doubling was crazily unnecessary; it ended up being over a foot high, of course, and I think it scared most of her friends a little, but the cake was deliciously simple, but not overwhelmed by it's dangerously rich counterparts.
I'd also like to say, I'm grateful that it's pointed out that the batter should be thin, I certainly would've thought something was wrong otherwise.
All in all...what a wonderful cake!
I need to try this! I usually make the regular Hershey's chocolate cake and everyone thinks I'm a baking wizard. It's so easy to change it up with the frosting too. A new favorite of mine is to use cannoli filling to frost and then top it off with candied citrus peels for decoration.
Faith,
What was the filling you used? It looks delicious.
I'm also wondering what your filling was.... looks like pecans?
I can't wait to make this cake for my boyfriend ^_^ First layer is in the oven right now actually, and the batter tastes AMAZING! it's like Dylan's Candyshop liquid brownies.
Made this yesterday-- delicious! Very moist and flavorful.
This is a wonderful chocolate cake! I also use hot boiling coffee in place of the water. My Aunt had this recipe back in the 60's hers called for a cup of oil instead of a 1/2 cup. I use these changes and also I have been using the Special Dark cocoa from hershey, it is wonderful. The first time I used the dark cocoa I used peanut butter frosting. Just the other day I made another one and forgot I was out of peanut butter. I made caramel sauce,poked holes in the cake and poured sauce over it. Melted some semi-sweet chocolate also poured this over the cake. Put back in oven for about 5 minutes. Very rich and very good. Kind of like a turtle cake.
This recipe is so perfect! I just made it. I halved the ingredients and used two 4.5" pans, for a mini cake (makes 4-6 slices). I used buttermilk in place of the milk, and hot coffee in place of the boiling water. It came out so rich and moist! I love how simple the recipe is! I made a few chocolate cakes over the past few days and hate how involved they are (sifting flour, creaming butter, etc...) This literally took me 10 minutes to whip up!
Very belated response to the questions about the filling! It was a German chocolate cake filling with coconut.
I think this is just what the doctor ordered or in my case what my son ordered! Tomorrow is his 17th birthday and I know he is feeling a bit under the weather (cold "bug" and achy muscles from track practice!) so wanted to make him something really special. Between this, Papa John's pizza (it kills me but he loves it!!), hot wings, Mountain Dew, and the new running shoes he should be one happy camper!
I love this recipe and i love the peanut butter frosting. i make it all the time but i use the one at Wilton.com still many props
Just found your website and loved this cake - perfect!!
I sometimes have to bake dairy free - have you ever made this cake with almond milk or soy milk in place or cows milk? Would love your thoughts on how to make it dairy free. thanks!
I wanted to make a cake for a birthday party tonight and this came together so fast, and looks beautiful. I added 1/2 tsp cayenne powder to the dries and it gives a subtle spicy amazingness.
I've got this cake in the oven as I type this. I was forced to substitute olive oil for the vegetable oil. I am hoping this turns out - the batter didn't taste odd. I did put a touch less oil in than recommended though. Anyhow, thanks for the recipe!
Thank for this beautiful cake, I am a clueless beginning baker and would like to know how you frosted it, looks like caramel with nuts.
The cake looks great...but with the frosting it looks scrumptious ! Would you please share that recipe too....Thanks
just tried these as cupcakes (as i've been looking for the perfect chocolate cupcake recipe)... they just came out of the oven and they seem pretty good so far!! ill have to see what the others think!
i initially baked for 20mins but they werent fully cooked so i baked for another 5