Summer means fresh garden produce, and fresh garden produced needs preserving as much as possible. So we turned to Tigress for a summer series on quick and easy pickling, which is just one way to preserve the bounty of summer a little longer. Last week she showed us quick pickled roots — this week, it's pickled mushrooms!
Welcome to the second installment of my quick pickling guest post series! Trust me on this one, if you've ever enjoyed gourmet deli-bought pickled mushrooms you are going to love these. If your ancestry hails from basically anywhere across the Atlantic, you probably have them in some form or another deep in your past. In other words, your grandma is going to love them. So, if you see a family picnic lurking anywhere in your future this summer, bring these. They will be a hit all around.
Let's talk general info for a moment. You might have noticed last week in the ingredient list of Quick Pickled Roots that I specified a one quart mason jar. This, because whenever you add boiling liquid to a glass jar you'll do best to make sure you are using a glass jar that is made to withstand severe and quick temperature changes. So by mason I mean the typical Ball or Kerr jars used for home canning. These can be the old-fashioned kind with the glass tops or the new ones with modern screw caps. If you still buy store-bought pickles (we can talk about that later) keep an eye out on those jars too as many of them will be marked 'Mason' right on the glass and are perfect to use for home quick picking.
For these lovelies, I use regular ole' white button mushrooms or the darker shaded Cremini. Feel free to experiment with other types, but stick to firm-fleshed varieties as they do best in the boil and deliver a soft pop between the teeth once good and pickled. And please, experiment with the herb variety! That's the fun of home quick pickles! You can do what you want to do. I used thyme in this jar, but I also suggest marjoram, parsley, celery leaves, oregano, summer savory, lovage, basil even. Or any combo thereof — maker's choice.
Quick Pickled 'Shrooms
1 1/2 pounds mushrooms
2 to 3 sprigs thyme, or herb of choice
1 small spring onion or small shallot, thinly sliced
1 1/2 teaspoons whole allspice
1 tablespoon black peppercorns
3 bay leaves
1 tablespoon sea salt
1/3 cup white wine vinegar
3/4 cups water
Special equipment
1 quart Mason jar
Wash mushrooms by quickly running them under cold water and wiping away any excess dirt with a damp cloth. Slice smaller mushrooms in half and large ones in quarters.
Place herb sprigs directly in the clean mason jar.
Add remaining ingredients to medium saucepan and bring to the boil. Reduce the heat and simmer for fifteen minutes.
Pour the hot mushrooms and liquid into jar and let cool. When mushrooms are cooled, cap the jar and place in the fridge. Mushrooms will be ready to eat in three days.
These Quick Pickled 'Shrooms will last in the fridge for up to one month. If you're planning to bring them to a picnic be careful. Because once you start tasting them, they quickly disappear, like magic!
Don't miss the last in the series! Next week - Quick Pickled Berries.
(Images: Hungry Tigress)

Comments (10)
WANT. THESE. NOW.
Me too Facciata. Besides snacking, what could these be used in/for? Anyone?
Question - is there any issue with boiling vinegar in a metal saucepan?
@alyssabean - as long as it is stainless or enameled cast iron you are good. you don't want to cook anything acidic in aluminum or iron.
I LOVE pickled mushrooms. They're an old favourite my Polish grandma makes all the time (shes an expert forager). My husband thinks that its the weirdest texture and says its gross. The mushrooms get a slightly slimy texture which often leads to the "acquired taste" category.
Could I can these like I do with other pickles in a hot water bath instead?
Can I cap these hot and let them achieve a vacuum seal in the jar? Not sure why they have to cool before capping. Thanks
@veronicaina - the acid level in this recipe is not high enough to seal in a waterbath safely. you'll want to put this right in the fridge.
@greybeard - you could cap them right away, but they would keep cooking a bit so the texture could be softer than you want. important though - whether capped or cooled and capped, this recipe is not shelf stable. keep them in the fridge.
To add to JMcC's comment, my Belorussian grandfather picked and pickled mushrooms, and they had a gelatinous liquid. We'd add a jar of mushrooms to sauteed onions and garlic, sour cream and lots of fresh dill, and serve on a bed of polenta, usually accompanied with a roast chicken. It's delicious beyond belief.
mmm, we used 1/3 dry sherry and 2/3 white vinegar for the wine vinegar. SO GOOD! Thanks for sharing your recipe, it's tasty and easy too :)