We're all about re-inventing the classics around here, and Thanksgiving is no exception. For example, for the last six years, I've celebrated Thanksgiving abroad with a healthy portion of gallo pinto (Costa Rican rice and beans), sand in my toes and surf in my ears. This is a move that has annoyed the parts of my family that stay state-side. So this year I threw my mom a cookie and asked if she would have us to her house in California for an early celebration.
"Let's keep it simple," was my only instruction.
For two food professionals — that's mom and me — this was a weighty exercise in restraint. The task at hand was to balance the desire to chill out while also keeping it classy. We succeeded, sort of.
Before you even embark on this task of hosting a Thanksgiving meal, ask yourself why you're doing it and what you want to get out of it. Do you want to be grumpy and stressed out? I didn't think so. I think the perfect balance is about serving beautiful food, not too much of it (why did mom and I make two different potato dishes? 5 points off for that!) and also keeping it festive. At my house, cloth napkins, good music and a little lipstick go a long way. The moment when I knew the meal came together wasn't when the stuffing came out perfectly crisped on the tops, it was when we all ended up dancing on the patio, wine glasses in hands.
Here are a few ideas for how you can dial down the Thanksgiving stress this year:
1) Ask for help and be open to unexpected helping hands. You'd be surprised how much of the meal isn't about cooking. For someone like me who actually likes to cook, having the other elements taken care of (shoot we're out of ice! can someone fold all the napkins?) takes a huge load off.
For our dinner, my cousin Kristin, a culinary school student, carved the bird. My aunt Suzi, a whizkid with flowers, made a centerpiece. My cousin Madliene brought wine. My dad bought ice and firewood and did all that dirty work. My five year old daughter added her own flair with some foil snowflake sculptures that she hung with kitchen twine from the light fixture. They were not magazine quality decor, but yet they were perfect in every way.
2) Do as much ahead as possible. Here are some things you can do days ahead. Start now!
- make salad dressing, the just re-whisk right before serving
- make the pie dough and let it rest in the fridge
- make the cranberry sauce
- cube bread and let it get stale (this is a good thing when it comes to stuffing) Best to let it sit out on a baking sheet or paper bag.
- defrost your bird if it's frozen (a 20-pounder will take four days)
- set the table
3) Don't worry about getting all the dishes on the table warm. My trick is to make sure you have really good gravy and it's hot. People pour that stuff over their whole plate anyway.
4) Let go a little. Things like mis-matched silverware and plates, bare feet and at least one cooking mistake make the whole things real. Guests feel welcome and at home when they realize that you, too, are imperfect. Who knows; you might even find people are getting tipsy and dancing on the patio. That's something to be thankful for. I know I am.
Remember that the recipes can be re-tried, but the spirit around a Thanksgiving table cannot be replicated. That spirit is unique and magical, like a snowflake, come and gone in an instant. Enjoy it.
Related: How to Cook a Turkey: The Simplest, Easiest Method
(Images: Sara Kate Gillingham-Ryan)

Comments (20)
ADORE that carving shot!! That there is some INTENSITY on her eye!! Thank you for the reminder that we all need to get our chillax on!
IN her eye. oopsie. Although that would be an interesting thing to see intensity ON someone's eye. :) Sounds like an eyeshadow...
Loved this article. Simple is always best!
My family did hamburgers at Christmas Eve for years. Simple and delicious!
Beautiful article SK.
I love the idea of delegating. As much as I enjoy cooking, it would just stress me out to no end to have to do it all myself. We are taking care of 3 dishes and providing the drinks, everything else is being brought by other family members. And despite my type-A tendencies, I wouldn't have it any other way.
Don't just defrost the pie dough, make the whole pie a day or so in advance. That's my mom's method, and the lady makes six pies each year!
Thank you for giving me permission to let some things go. I love that your family felt so comfortable that they danced on the patio. I think this Thanksgiving will be a bit different for us now. Great article.
We have pizza on Christmas eve, every single year. And for the 5 years preceding last Thanksgiving/Christmas/Easter we ate at the dining facility at a small remote Air National Guard Base in Alaska. It was wonderful because they employed several professional chefs who were given liberty as to what all they made. (plus you could go back for more and take home your leftovers at no extra cost!) It was like having dinner with a huge extended family to include the eccentric "uncle" who loved to pull out the torch in order to carmelize the creme brules for the kiddos to watch! I truly miss it now that we've moved but loved every minute of it while there!
I ask my guests to contribute desserts and appetizers. That way I can concentrate on the meal. Plus, fitting my own dishes into the oven is enough of a puzzle without having to worry about everyone else's!
By the way, I loved this post. I'm all for stress free holidays! Once you've done Thanksgiving enough times you realize that it's not that difficult. Master the turkey recipe and you're halfway there.
The day before Thanksgiving, I'm making two side dishes that reheat well, making the gravy, cubing the bread and dicing the carrots, celery and onions for the stuffing. Also cleaning the house.
On Thursday, toss in the bird, cook the stuffing, reheat everything else, and gratefully receive dessert, cranberry sauce and appetizers from guests. Oh yeah--and open wine and enjoy the day!
I'm excited to try my newest approach to simple turkey. I cut it into pieces, cured it 24 hrs. in salt and spices and now I'll confit it in olive oil for 12 hrs, cool & store in the oil until T-day. Then the pieces just get reheated to crisp the skin before serving. I’m not hung up on presenting a whole bird, and I love that I could actually do this a month or more ahead if I wanted to. I'm also pre-making stock with the spare bones so gravy will be simple the day of. Can't wait to see how this works out. Might be a new tradition.
A wonderful reminder that, although the meal is what brings us together, it's really about enjoying the event and the people. After reading this, I think our celebration plans sound just about right!
love it. thanks.
Okay, gotta ask: what music got people to dance on the patio?
Do you have any other playlist insights?
What's your flavor, mschatelaine? I believe the playlist went from Afrobeat to Katy Perry/Snoop Dogg to old R&B.
I would endless explore different side options if left to my own devices, so I made a rule for myself that there would only be one "new" dish every year and if it sucks, that's okay.
For the first time in 6 years, I am allowing people to bring things other than beverages to my thanksgiving meal! Having a toddler will make you realize that attempting to do it all yourself is stupid. ;-) I've also decided to keep the menu simple. I have mashed potatoes, so I cut the sweet potatoes. And only 2 pies for dessert. (Normally I'd make 3-4). Having only one tiny euro size oven, I cook nearly everything the day before, refrigerate, then on the day of, allow to come to room temp and reheat while the turkey is resting/being carved and I'm making the gravy.
You can cook the turkey so it's ready 2 hours or more in advance, then wrap it in towels and blankets and leave it in a warm place while you cook the vegetables. It'll still be hot when you come to carve it, and it also continues cooking a bit inside, reducing the risk of underdone parts. We did this last year and it worked very well.