The movement for the last many years has been toward kitchens that are open to living and dining spaces. However, we still love a closed kitchen, set aside as a room with a completely different function from the living spaces. Here are a few that really drive it home for us:
First off, an open kitchen wouldn't generally have a need for a charming door like this one from the Michelle Cooks with Art kitchen tour. These bi-swinging doors with the circular window are a kitchen classic that many of us still want, despite the greater movement to kitchens without doors at all. When entertaining, it can be such a convenience to have the kitchen separated from the public spaces of the home.
Next, no one says a closed kitchen has to feel claustrophobic. A glass door leading to the outdoors can bring in tons of views and sunshine and allow direct access to an outdoor eating area without opening your kitchen to the rest of the home.
Finally, we love the snug and compact feeling of an enclosed galley kitchen. In the third image above, you'll see a narrow galley kitchen with everything within reach. The only thing we're questioning here is the placement of the dishwasher, which is pretty puzzling. Otherwise, we love the narrow proportions of a closed-in galley where you simply turn and turn again throughout the preparation of a meal.
What about you? Do you, like us, throw back to the days when kitchens were enclosed? Or do you prefer they be open to the more public spaces of the house like the living room?
Related: Open vs. Closed Kitchens: Which Do You Prefer?
(Images: Jill Slater, Jessica Helgerson, House to Home)




Comments (27)
when my daughter was tiny and toddling open kitchens made lots of sense. it meant that I had her with an eye's reach most of the day without having to rush through my cooking to get back to the other room.
now? well, its just not that much of an issue and how lovely (and relaxing) would it be to not have to keep the kitchen immaculate and company-ready every second of the day. i love a clean kitchen... no doubt, but to have it pretty enough to look at at the end of every day when i am ready to sit on the couch is exhausting sometimes.
the second kitchen pictured is gorgeous and an enclosed kitchen would be lovely as long as there is a nook somewhere for a chair or two. company is nice on those days that are filled with morn-to-eve cooking.
I would dearly love to be able to hide my disaster of a kitchen when company comes over but some past resident or the management of my apartment decided to remove the doors so that's not an option any more.
On the other hand, I love being able to put the finishing touches on whatever I'm serving while still chatting with my friends and that's not possible with an entirely closed kitchen.
I think there is a sense of mystery with a closed kitchen. The food you bring out for your guests can be that much more dramatic since they can't see what you are doing. I have an open kitchen and like it pretty much with the exception that I wished the work area faced the rest of the living area.
Oh, open kitchen all the way. I like to multi-task when I'm cooking or just puttering in the kitchen--watch TV, talk to my husband on the couch, etc. I'm not a die-hard, serious foodie cook, but I spend a lot of time in the kitchen and I'd hate to have it shut away from the rest of the house.
I'm so glad to have a pocket door between my kitchen and living/dining room. No one needs to look at the carnage in the kitchen while eating what came out of it. I'd swap my solid door for one with a porthole window any time though!
I wouldn't have put the dishwasher there in the third photo, either (what's wrong with "next to the sink"?). But then again, I wouldn't have my washing machine in the kitchen. It's one of my least favourite aspects of kitchen design in the UK.
I live in a 1929 bungalow with a 10X13 kitchen at the back of the house in its own room. It has two large banks of windows and quite decent work space. I love it. It is off a back hall where the pantry is, and has enough room for an island with seating. We eat in there a lot, it is a gathering place when people are over, yet we don't have to look at dirty dishes during a meal in the dining room.
I'm just not a huge fan of open living spaces generally.
put me in the closed kitchen camp. I have a doorway between my large dining room and my kitchen. Some previous owner of this 100 year old house had removed the door. I would love to replace it with a swinging door. A porthole window would be fantastic. I don't understand this kitchen-as-showplace trend. Kitchens are the hardest working spaces in our homes (other than bathrooms) and need to be utilitarian first. Nothing wrong with creating pleasant surroundings in kitchens, but all this need for granite and stainless steel this-and-that and cabinets with fancy doors and molding (that are a pain to clean). I cook in my kitchen. I cook every day. I need a space with plenty of light and surfaces that are durable and easy to clean. When I am done cooking (which I enjoy immensly), I want to close the door on the mess and enjoy my meal in my dining room!
There are obvious benefits to each, so why don't you try to take the best of both with a hybrid design? For example, a galley kitchen with a big pass through window on one side, with a simple island on the other side of the wall. You would be able to hide the dirty dishes on one side, while finishing off food and entertaining on the other.
I know if sounds expensive with essentially two kitchens, but depending on how you implement it, you might actually be surprised at its affordability. Especially when you consider the 'back' kitchen does not need to be finished with expensive cabinetry - think a utilitarian pantry with a sink and dishwasher. And the 'front' kitchen needs less expensive cabinetry since a lot of the storage is already in the back.
Although I like the idea of an open kitchen, I much prefer the reality of a closed one. Reason number one is food smell. Nothing is worse than the left over smells of dinner wafting throughout the house for hours or days after cooking.
Baking break or cookies smells wonderful. Lamb, fish, or anything with a lot of spice can smell terrible after the fact. And, as others pointed out, you can close off the kitchen mess from diners or guests and shut out dishwasher noise, etc.
A closed-off kitchen is a luxury, and one I heartily appreciate.
I'm often amazed at some of the new apts in NYC in which the kitchen is just one wall of the living room -- even old communist worker housing was more luxurious than that!
I am constantly frustrated when I'm at my parents house using their open kitchen. I'll try to get a snack, do some dishes, or make dinner and my mom will pause the tv because of the noise. I feel like I can't use the kitchen except during designated "dinner making" time.
My husband and I have a house built in the mid-60s, and we sort of have the best of both worlds. The kitchen is closed off from the formal dining room and formal living area, but there is a family room to which the kitchen is open. My husband wants to get rid of all interior doors on the first floor, except for the ones to the basement and bathroom. I, however, appreciate the practicality of having a kitchen that at least *can* be closed off from the rest of the house. I had wanted a pocket door, but the walls don't allow it (not without significant electrical reconfiguring). I'm hoping we can get double French doors that swing both ways and can also be pushed to stay open, if desired. I haven't found that yet, though.
I'm for a kitchen that is large enough to accommodate some socializing but closed enough to contain cooking smells and screen off the view from the dining area. I don't really have either now but my last kitchen did and I loved it.
I have a closed kitchen with a double swinging door into the dining room similar to the photo above. Although I like my closed kitchen I really like the window in the door in that photo. For me that would be a great addition to my door. I could look out if needed but it could also avert a catastrophe when carrying things in and our of the kitchen.
Keep the door closed!! Small NY apartments can accommodate pocket doors, barn doors, bi-fold doors. I don't need my living room sofa to smell like fish or broccoli.
When I moved into my 1948 home, the (standard-sized) door to the dining room had been removed. After using the kitchen as-is for 4 years, I decided to increase the width of the doorway from 30" to 54" for several reasons:
1. Heat! With the kitchen open to the rest of the house, heat disburses much more quickly. (I already had a powerful vent-fan and the kitchen still got unbearably hot--I live in the South.)
2. Circulation. Having a wider door makes it much easier to set the table, serve food & drinks, and mingle at parties. The small door was always a terrible bottle-neck.
3. Visual space. My kitchen and dining room together are probably a little under 200 square feet total. Divided, both felt small and cramped. More open, they now feel much larger!
4. Light. I live in a townhouse that is not an end-unit. This means that every ounce of light coming from the outdoors is precious. Allowing light to pass more easily from room to room makes the space feel more open, airy, and bright!
Under different circumstances, I could see having a closed kitchen. But for me, the "pros" of opening it up far outweighed the "cons."
I love having a closed kitchen, a galley-ish kitchen with a window over the sink, a back door with a window as well, and a door into the dining room and one into the hallway. I really do not like the open kitchen/ family room look.
I really wish I could shut my whiny cats out of the kitchen. Not only for when I want to leave something to cool on the counter without it being investigated, but also because they are under the impression that whatever I'm doing requires their supervision.
My husband and I designed our home with a swinging door in the kitchen and it wasn't completely finished when we moved in. I liked it off, the connection to the rest of the house is nice, but cooking smells wafting other places is a problem.
Then came kids and a swinging door presented problems, so it stayed off. Now they are a bit bigger and I'm wanting the door back again, but also want to open a pass-through to the dining room so I can see out to it and the backyard.
It is the heart of our home, but not everyone needs to see the open heart surgery been performed.
Our 1914 apartment has a kitchen that is not only closed, but down the hall. It saddens me for entertaining, as well as cleaning up while bf is in another room. I do like closing the cats out on occasion, but my dream place has a very open kitchen.
I grew up with a totally open kitchen, and never remember food smells being a problem...
I live in a hybrid design I guess. Every room is distinct from one another, but there are no doors, just an open hallway connecting each room. My kitchen has a breakfast area, and when I cook, people like to hang out at the table to chat with me.
I grew up in modern houses, so maybe I'm still rebelling. Just as I love the rest of our old (1920), quirky, small-roomed house, I love the closed kitchen. So much so that I'm currently debating finishing the reno by putting back the swinging door into the dining room - it looks like it's been missing for at least 30 years, but I'm betting I could find one at the salvage yard.
The kitchen has a wonderful breakfast nook where company or a teenager hang out while the cook is in service, and there's a nice intimacy in that amount of space. When we have company, everybody divvies up into nice, conversation-sized group, with one always in the kitchen. And, as several folks have said, I can wait to do the dishes 'til the crowd goes home and not feel bad.
Closed Kitchens! Yes, the smell. Doesn't blend with the decor once you're in digesting mode, or even the next morning. You can concentrate on efficient work without distractions, and once the food comes through those doors to the crisp white tablecloth, it's magical. Afterward it all can be whisked out of site and smell to enjoy the evening. Had both, again have a small compact kitchen adjoining a vast space, and it's totally modern.
When we remodel we're going to have a kitchen/diner which has double doors to the sitting room. I wouldn't want a separate dining room since we tend to hang out in the kitchen while one or both of us cooks, but it is lovely to be able to shut the door on it all after dinner and retire to the sitting room, or to have guests who never have to go into the kitchen. We should be able to open it up all the way though in the summer or when we want to entertain big gatherings.
I think it's a very personal preference since there are pluses and minuses for either option. Open kitchens can make a home feel larger, but closing off the space can contain cooking smells and the general messiness of preparing food from the view of guests. Either consideration might be particularly relevant for small homes.
@lemonadefish -- down the hall does sound lonely...as if you're in the staff kitchen where the help is out of sight.
been thinking about this a lot the past few weeks as i brace myself for the next two months of cooking in the summer in texas. you mean i could turn the oven on and it would only warm up the kitchen?!? so there...