It takes a fairly big kitchen to pull off this look. And to be honest, we're thinking the most useful ones would be custom-made, so they'd fit perfectly with the size of the island.
Plus, wouldn't they be heavy to pull out in order to slide in? Much more work than simply alighting on a stool to watch a friend prep dinner.
• See the kitchen above: Alabama Lake House, in House Beautiful.
Here's one counter-height bench we love, though. It looks manageable, size-wise. And the tufting!
Have you seen benches at islands in anyone's kitchen? What do you think of this look?
(Images: Christopher Baker; Four Hands)