In honor of eating a bit lighter this month we've made effort to scale back when it comes to sugar and fat. This recipe from The Hummingbird Bakery in London is packed with all the taste with far less guilt than a standard cheesecake brings you. Plus it tastes like sunshine on a plate and who wouldn't want that?
This recipe is a treat to make and a treat to eat, plus there's no worry about cracking tops and water baths. This cheesecake involves gelatin and is set in your refrigerator. Just make sure to mush your bananas thoroughly, let your cream cheese soften before mixing and use the correct size pan. We went a slight bit smaller and the result (although tasty) was a taller and slightly less stable cake.
We also feel obligated to tell you that the addition of hot fudge sauce over the top makes this cake like a banana split on a plate. Though it defeats the point of eating light, it's still darn good eats!
Icebox Banana Cheesecake
Yields: 10-12 slices
The Humming Bird Bakery
6 1/2 ounces graham crackers
1 stick plus 2 tablespoons unsalted butter
1 1/2 envelopes granulated gelatin
1 cup mashed banana
1/3 cup orange juice
10 ounces cream cheese
1/2 cup sugar
3 egg yolks
1 cup heavy cream
Break graham crackers and put them in a food processor (or zip top bag) and pulse until finely ground. Slowly add melted butter and pulse to combine. Press into the base of a 9" spring form pan (with parchment paper on bottom). Refrigerate.
Pour 1/3 cup water into a small bowl. Sprinkle gelatin into the water and set aside for 5 minutes. Put banana and orange juice into a small sauce pan over medium heat and cook until banana is cooked through (5-8 minutes). Remove from heat and set aside.
Put cream cheese, egg yolk, sugar in the bowl of a mixer with the paddle attachment (or use a handheld whisk) and beat slowly until mixture it smooth and thick. In a separtate bowl whip cream until thick but not stiff. Set aside.
Stir the soaked gelatin into the warm, not hot, banana mixture and stir until gelatin is evenly dispersed. Spoon a little cream cheese mixture into the banana mixture and stir to mix. Then add a little more. This will even out the temperatures of the two resulting in evently spread gelatin and uncooked egg yolks. Continue until all is combined and slowly fold in whipped cream with a wooden spoon until combined.
Pour into prepared shell and chill for two hours, or overnight. Enjoy!
• Related: 2 Minute (Microwaved) Lime Cheesecake
(Image: Sarah Rae Trover)
Monterey Pitcher fr...

I fail to see where this recipe qualifies as "lighter eating". Full-fat cream cheese, heavy cream, egg yolks and a stick of butter??? It looks good, but I would categorize it as a full-fat dessert.
Yes this recipe has full fat (*gasp*) cream cheese and butter. The butter is only in the crust, so if you'd like to lessen that amount or use a substitute, please do so. The cream cheese on the other hand, Low-Fat or Light cream cheese isn't an acceptable substitute for anyone concerned about taste. So we stuck with it since it's only a little more than 1 brick and assuming you're not eating the entire cake yourself, we're still ok with that.
A typical New York style cheesecake takes upwards of 6 bricks of cream cheese, at least 3 times the sugar, and even more eggs. In our book, this is a great lighter substitution with slightly less guilt.
While I sympathize with the "eat real fat in desserts in moderation" theory of menu planning rather than "eat fat-free dairy products as much as you want" theory, I'm with the first poster - in my house, this would be an indulgence dessert, given the cream. I guess what is "lighter" just depends on your perspective.
"...assuming you're not eating the entire cake yourself" was your first mistake.
I dunno gelatin cream 1 stick of cream cheese some sugar some juice is much much better than 6 sticks of cream cheese cream sugar sugar in my book.
Here's a comparison, done up really quick. ~400 calories per serving still is a lot for dessert if you're on a diet but its all in making sure its in moderation. Sure as hell better than ~800 calories!
Here's this recipe:
http://caloriecount.about.com/icebox-banana-cheesecake-recipe-r320090
And here's your standard cheesecake recipe:
http://allrecipes.com/Recipe/Banana-Cream-Cheesecake/Detail.aspx
i would rather have the real deal as a rare treat rather than maker a lower (although not low) fat version.
i cant figure out how the eggs get cooked by stirring in warm cream?
@syrupandhoney Every little bit helps. Why not have a lower calorie treat :D
Anyway, I wouldn't make something like this unless I *knew* it would be eaten by others as well as myself.
Life is too short to crab about 1 package of cream cheese and a stick of butter - enjoy life a little, people. Cream, butter, eggs, chocolate, sunshine, all so enjoyable. What a miserable life it would be if we didn't get any pleasure out of things like that.
I'm with the first poster.
Yeah, I agree with anb - I don't see how the egg yolks get cooked. Though I'm not afraid of uncooked eggs (we know *exactly* where our eggs come from), it still seems a little odd in this type of dessert.
kate78--
And, um, it gets shorter if you don't.
You obviously are pleased with your weight, don't have diabetes in your family, have whistle-clean arteries and can eat in moderation. Good for you!
I think the initial objection was having this recipe live under a "lighter eating" banner. Not that "dessert = evil."
But as evidenced above, it's all highly relative, so yes, cut yourself a piece of cake!
Funny to me, I am on a low-carb eating plan right now that precludes even fruit carbs... so the bananas and graham crackers are more verboten to me right now than are the eggs or cream cheese!
I think the only thing needed is to point out that this recipe is compared to regular cheesecake... not that it's actually diet food! I think it looks excellent!
I like the idea of the bananas and orange juice for flavor - I think I'll try to incorporate that into my cream cheese/whipped topping mixture fake cheese cake.
"far less guilt than a standard cheesecake brings you"
I don't feel guilty about eating. Can this site drop this nonsense, please?
The tag line is "inspiring cooks, nourishing homes". which is sort of silly, as nourishment is for living organisms, but anyway--I'm not inspired by suggestions that I'm supposed to feel guilty for eating something.
I'll be trying this dessert this weekend. Thanks Sarah!
@jamina1 I'm not sure I understand your comment that every little bit helps. Every little bit of what? I'm with Palmetto that I don't associate food with guilt, and am all the healthier for it.
kate78, THANK YOU for your post. I'm with you on this one. Life's too short. Perhaps even shorter with cream cheese, but oh so tasty.
I made this cheesecake today. I think I may have used a little more than half the second packet of gelatin (next kitchen post-divorce purchase will be a scale). The texture was a little too firm. The flavor was good though. It screams for pineapple but since gelatin and pineapple don't get along I understand the omission. I think this would be a great summer dessert.
Where I disagree with kate78 is the false dichotomy--artery-clogging unhealthy food and eating pleasure versus healthy food and suffering for health. There are many wonderful things to eat that are actually good for you. You don't have to load things up with saturated fat and sugar in order to eat well and "enjoy life a little."
I would make this if it weren't for the raw eggs.
And yes, can we drop the invocations of guilt (or guiltlessness)? Health is a different matter and requires less moralizing.
Gelatin, yuck!
I find it humorous that people will always find something to complain about. Can't make everyone happy.
As for the no bake cheesecake with gelatin, I grew up with my mom making an oreo crust with the same type of cheesecake middle.
Thank you The Kitchn for always posting different and delightful sounding recipes. I come here to look for recipes because I know there will always be a different twist to everyday ingredients or food
Anything with a graham cracker crust has me swooning.