Sent by Alexis Editor: Alexis, when we spill something majorly sticky like this, our approach is usually to just use lots and lots of very hot water. You could try soaking a kitchen cloth in boiling water and laying it over the honey to soften it. Then wipe as much honey as you can off the shelf, and then repeat. Eventually, when you've wiped off enough honey for it to be just a sticky residue, use more hot water and soap (and maybe some Goo-Gone!) to get the last of it.
In our experience, cleaners just haven't worked as well in this particular situation. It comes down to lots of really, really hot water, and elbow grease!
Readers, do you have any tips, tricks, or especially good methods for cleaning up honey spills?
Related: Good Question: Best Honey Dispenser?
(Image: Alexis via email)