A couple weeks ago Amanda Hesser's Recipe Redux column in The Times Magazine had a recipe for some very unusual pancakes. They flipped the usual pancake recipe ratios upside down and called for two cups of sour cream, four eggs, and only a scant handful of flour to hold it all together. They sounded unusual, and tricky, but Hesser called them "feathery, creamy, tangy." How could we not try them?

A first batch of Heavenly Hots: predictably smushed.
My husband and I are big fans of pancakes. He follows in his father's footsteps by making light and delicious buttermilk pancakes; they're a special weekend treat. But last weekend we decided to give these even lighter pancakes a try. They sorely tested our pancake skills, that's for sure! But they were unusual and so worth it.
Heavenly Hots are a classic breakfast hit from a restaurant in Berkeley, California. They seem to be based on the Russian blini, with sour cream substituted for milk, and a tangy, lighter texure than the traditional American pancake.
Here were our thoughts on this recipe.
• The process: First of all, this batter is very loose and thin. It's more like crepe mix than thick, puffy pancake batter. The recipe cautions you to create very small pancakes — no more than three inches in diameter. We found this to be an important note; anything bigger and these will be impossible to flip.
Flipping them was so tricky; even at silver dollar size they were very hard to flip without tearing them. My husband (champion pancake-flipper!) got the the hang of it after a smushed batch or too. He figured out how to slide the spatula underneath and coax the little pancake up and over.
These cook very quickly, but it's difficult to make more than three or four at a time. And three or four pancakes definitely won't feed a hungry breakfast-eater; a full batch of these would feed 2 to 4 people. So you really have to wait until they are all cooked before sitting down to eat.
• The taste: As promised, these were amazingly light. All that work pays off into a really creamy pancake, with a soft and tender middle, and a butter-crisped top. They didn't need much maple syrup! They practically melt in your mouth. My only quibble was that I tasted egg more than I tasted sour cream; I think I had this vision of pure sour cream in pancake form, but these are definitely more eggy than not.
• The verdict: These were delicious little pancakes, and a real departure from the fluffier American pancake. But their trickiness and the fact that you do so much work to create so many little pancakes makes this recipe less practical than more traditional pancakes. We'll definitely make these again, but they don't replace our old-fashioned buttermilk pancakes.
• Get the recipe: Heavenly Hots at The New York Times
Have you tried these yet?
Related: Recipe: Fluffy Ricotta Pancakes
(Images: Faith Durand)










Comments (7)
I recently made this recipe also. Here's the trick to flipping--a fish spatula! That's right. I didn't have any problems at all. :) This recipe sounds weird but tastes fantastic so give it a try. Think of the mostly flipsy spatula possible (with no open areas in the main part). Because of the crisco, it slides under the pancake easily and the crisco also keeps the thin batter from spreading too far. I used a tablespoon to portion batter on to the griddle and it worked well!
Is there a link somewhere to your buttermilk pancake recipe, Faith? We, too, are big pancake fans. This recipe sounds a little too time consuming for a mom with a little baby constantly pulling my pant legs, but thanks for posting.
My husband has been making these on Sunday morning for many years. It's not hard to keep them warm in a low oven if you're feeding a crowd.
They're my very favorite and even make our "breakfast for dinner" rotation on occasion.
The original recipe is in Marion Cunningham's "Breakfast Cookbook" which is still available.
This is a variation of the pancake recipe which is now the standard in our house (pretty much every Sunday).
Ours is a bit different though -- the egg whites are whipped stiff, making them even lighter and fluffier. It also gives the batter more body, and easier to cook.
I don't especially want the taste of sour cream in the middle of the pancake, and so am very happy with these.
Our recipe is from the cookbook "Recipe from Home" (we skip the cinnamon in the original recipe).
I was trying to recreate "Elaine's Special Pancakes" from Mitchell London's Café at the Fairway Market on the UWS -- those to me epitomize the best pancakes ever. Someone on Chowhound said they thought they were made with sour cream and beaten egg whites, and that such a recipe was popularly circulated in the '50s, at a time Mitchell's mom (Elaine) would have been making pancakes for Mitchell...
(sleuthing pancakes...!)
I tried these last week and they were fantastic! Very light compared to other pancakes I've had. It is true that it does not make a lot of them but it is still a nice treat.
Your description makes these sound amazing. Now I'm hungry :)
I made these after ripping the recipe out of Gourmet magazine in the last year and a half.:( I LOVE these.