Last Thursday I gave a controversial assignment as part of Week Two of The Kitchn Cure: I asked you to pitch your processed foods.
And the questions started rolling in about what, exactly, processed foods are?
Processed food is basically food that has been changed from its natural state for the sake of shelf life and safety, or for the sake of convenience. It all started when in the late 19th century, thanks to the invention of the refrigerator to keep food, and the train to transport it across great distances, we began to believe that we deserved to have food that lasted longer than when it was plucked from the earth, or caught running across our property.
Foods are processed in a variety of ways: canning, freezing, chopping, peeling, liquefying, fermenting, frying, gasification, spray drying, mixing, baking, and other cooking with other methods like boiling and grilling. Most of those don't sound so bad, do they? After all, preserving food has an important place in food history, and there are some wonderful, healthy, ways of preserving foods. However, the processed food industry has largely gone too far in terms of chemicals and additives.
It is true that fresh produce and raw meats, are more likely to be hosts for pathogenic micro-organisms like Salmonella than, say, a can of Spam or boiled beets. The problem is that most methods used to process foods not only remove nutrients and flavor from foods, but give us a false sense of safety about our food.
For example, Vitamin C is destroyed by heat and so canned fruits have less Vitamin C than fresh ones. In general, the further from its original source food gets, both in distance and form, the less nutrients and flavor it holds onto.
Take the peach, for example. Peeling it isn't so bad. Neither is boiling it, really. But peeling, boiling, immersing it in high fructose corn syrup, and then canning it leaves you with a food product that's far from its original source. The thing you have in that can in your hand in early spring has little in common with the thing hanging on the tree during the summer.
Ask yourself, do I need these canned peaches? Now, if you must, look for ones that are not sweetened. Maybe in this case frozen fresh organic peaches are a better bet.
Now, of course, a sack of flour, for example, is a processed food when taking the term literally. But there is a greater difference between bleached and bromated all-purpose white flour (what most Americans use) and whole grain flour, or even unbleached, unbromated white flour. If you're staring at your flour and wondering if you have to toss it because it is, yes, technically processed, do some critical thinking about how far off the flour is from its original state, and also, how useful it is to you.
I'm not suggesting you pitch all flour: I keep whole wheat and organic all-purposed unbleached white flour in my cupboard, because I use both. I see no reason, however, to ever use bleached flour, unless you want a perfectly white cake. And that's silly. Bleached flour has a slightly lower percentage of protein, if that's a concern to you, but I'm guessing we're not dealing in such baking detail, at least not yet.
Monterey Pitcher fr...

I see how bleached flour is unnecessary, but what exactly is bromating? How big a difference does bromating make?
I started throwing out processed foods before the Cure started (actually, I'm giving them away on Freecycle), but my S/O refuses to let me get rid of some stuff (such as his canned fruit and boxed pasta mixes), so I haven't had complete success.
This is just kind of dumb. So Jelly, which isn't much like real fruit, should be thrown out? I like Jelly. I make my own Jelly. I'm never going to be parted with my jelly.
And how about chocolate, and cheese, and coffee? All very processed. Olive oil and wine are also processed.
Blah.
I think the better guide would be to remove items where you can't pronounce the word or you don't have a clue what it is. Except in your emergency box. Must keep an emergency box.
I am not throwing any food away unless it's outdated. With the economy the way that it is, that would be silly. I happen to live in a rural area so giving it away is also not an option. SO, I decided to cut back on my purchases and try not to buy any MORE processed food that was needed. Except, as Kassie says, you have to have food (and water) in your emergency kit. 3 days worth at least. And the foods that last without refridgeration are processed.
So you guys don't used canned tomatoes? Anything pickled is bad like olives or capers...not so sure about this. I just can't see it. My mom cans her own tomatoes and while they are heat processed they taste a heck of a lot better than any of the "fresh" anemic tomatoes you get in winter. I'd hate to make a pasta using those. Sure you could say I need to stick to seasonal produce but then seasonal where? I've had nectarines that were shipped in from Chile in the dead of winter(their summer) which were actually better than the stuff I get in the summer here. And if you say it has to be local then that rules out citrus and where would we be without lemons? This all seems pretty arbitrary to me. It's a lot like the concept of eating healthy, we all have some idea what it means but it's impossible to define precisely.
I understand the intent here, eat fresh, in-season, but I am also not throwing away food items. I am planning on not buying foods that have ingredients that read like a scientific report. I'm not so great at science!
I had a hard time with this task as well. I live in a very rural area which is occasionally cut off from all shopping areas (it's an island). We eat fresh from local farms and our own produce on a day-to-day basis, but my storehouse of canned foods are of great comfort to me in case of emergency. Our last big blackout lasted for two weeks, so I think I'll be hanging onto my canned peaches for the moment. ;-)
This argument seems a bit spurious. It's one thing to avoid preservatives and other food additives that we don't know what they are, from whence they come, or what the long term effects of ingesting them are, but it's quite another to stop eating canned fruits and veggies.
It's true that vitamin C is easily destroyed by heat. But it's not true that canned vegetables lack vitamin C or other essential nutrients. After reading this post, I grabbed a can of Dole mandarin oranges out of my pantry and checked its stats: it contains a whopping 35% of the RDA of vitamin C per serving and some quick googling shows that is considered "very high" in vitamin C.
The fact is that unless you're relatively well off and live near a whole foods store or farmer's market, fresh produce year round is not possible or practical for most people on the planet. And it's not true that canning destroys nutritional value.
Besides, without the ability to can foods, how much would go to waste in rot?
You may want to avoid canned fruits that contain lots of added sugar or even (gasp) high-fructose corn syrup, but there are less sugary canned options out there. I just don't see a compelling scientific reason to break the bank trying to conform to some notion of an raw/organic utopia.
Ktoth, here's a link to Wikipedia about potassium bromate:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Potassium_bromate
Readers,
This is a great discussion we have going, and I'd like to chime in.
Perhaps I've been taken too literally. With this post, I simply intended to help you think about where your food comes from and how processed it has been. So, for example, a can of tomatoes, if simply canned, is better than a can of tomatoes that has artificial preservatives, coloring, or refined sugar. Of course we use canned tomatoes, sally599. Especially at this time of year!
And Kassie, you make your own jelly? Fantastic! (send us photos and recipes!) That is very different than buying, for example, Smucker's Concord Grape Jelly, which has among its ingredients both High Fructose Corn Syrup and Corn Syrup. I'm guessing, and hoping, yours doesn't.
Canning covers a wide range of processes. Not all processes are unhealthy, but it's a slippery slope - and there are distinctions between the more healthy end and the less healthy end. Preserving food is one thing, artificially processing food is another. And to me, personally, preserved food containing artificially processed ingredients (like high fructose corn syrup) is not a top pick.
We are definitely not trying to convince you to conform to some notion of a raw/organic utopia, as ahulsey puts it. Not at all. We certainly don't conform to one! We are merely trying to help you think more about how the food you have in your kitchen is made. And we hope that we are helpful.
To your health!
I'm hoping when you say "pitch" you mean donate to a soup kitchen...
B. Kate,
Thanks for the reminder: I meant to address that issue as well. In the previous posts for The Kitchn Cure, we have talked about deciding to give extra food away rather than throwing it in the garbage. It's up to you.
Here's pics of me making Easy Red Wine Jelly.
http://www.kassiechurch.net/2007/11/easy-red-wine-jelly.html
And here's me making all natural Jalapeno Jelly.
http://www.kassiechurch.net/2007/11/jalapano-jelly.html
I'm not doing the Kitchn cure persay, but checked ingredient labels around the kitchen anyway. I couldn't imagine pitching all my condiments, especially the cornerstones of my Chinese-based cooking, soy sauce and oyster sauce.
Mmmmm SPAM!
Jelly, chocolate, cheese and coffee, although different from their original form, are made using processes hundreds of years old, before the machine age. I would consider these products closer to natural than processed.