A family recipe is important, even if we don't remember all the parts, because each attempt at its re-creation keeps us connected to the people who helped shape us. It happens each time we do that intimate, life-sustaining cooking and eating thing, especially when we do it from a place of memory.
If there's one thing we Gilinghams can agree on, it's that Grandma Katie, my tall Irish namesake, made her Boston Baked Beans from Van Camp's canned Pork & Beans with ketchup, mustard and liquid smoke. When I reached out to relatives to ask about the details of Katie's beans, I realized there's a family dispute raging over whether or not there was canned chunk pineapple and sliced franks in the recipe, but I'm taking the position that there was; where else would all that character came from?
Mostly, I remember loving when she would come over with an armful of groceries and make me a pot of beans.
Not knowing I would some day become a food writer, Grandma Katie didn't write down her recipes for me. When she died I was too young to understand why I might one day want them, but I remember the flavors and the feeling I got when the house filled with the sweet and tangy aroma of this dish and I wanted to bring that feeling to my own home. So I recently tried reinventing them, replacing the canned beans with dried, and the hot dogs with thick slab bacon, but of course I kept the canned pineapple.
As I worked on the recipe this week, I smelled something I hadn't smelled for decades. Along with that earthen candy aroma, I could almost see my grandmother's tall lean frame, hear her sing-songy voice, feel her long tapered nails giving me a back scratch, and smell both her comforting powdery perfume and the cigarette smoke that would eventually take her away from us.
Cooking is a powerful trigger of memory. This is how we keep the ones we love alive. It doesn't really matter if you don't get the recipe right.

Baked Beans with Pineapple and Bacon
Serves 8 to 101 pound (about 2 1/4 cups) dried navy beans or Great Northern Beans
1/4 cup dark brown sugar
1/4 cup molasses
2 1/2 teaspoons dry mustard
1 teaspoon salt
1 15-oz can diced tomatoes
1 cup crushed pineapple (canned in juice or fresh)
1 bunch green onions, sliced into 1/2-inch pieces
8 thick slices smoked bacon
Rinse the beans and soak them in 6 cups of water overnight or at least 6 hours.*
Preheat the oven to 325°F.
Add beans with their soaking liquid to the pot. Combine the brown sugar, molasses, mustard, and salt, and pour the mixture over the beans. Add the tomatoes, pineapple, and all but 1/2 cup of the green onions. Stir the pot to combine the ingredients. Lay the bacon strips across the top of the beans.
Cover the pot and bake about 5 hours, until the beans are tender but not falling apart and mushy. Uncover during the last 30 minutes of cooking to allow the bacon to crisp.
Serve in bowls topped with a few pinches of sliced green onion.
*Bean Soaking Shortcut: For shorter soaking time, put the beans in their pot, cover with 6 cups water, bring to a rapid boil and cook on high for 2 minutes. Remove from the pot from the heat, cover it, and let it stand 1 hour before adding the mustard mixture and following the above directions.
Related: Beautiful Beans: 15 Delicious Recipes with Beans
(Images: Sara Kate Gillingham-Ryan)
3-Tier Cake Stand b...

Comments (19)
My daughter loves baked beans and I have been wanting to try to make them from scratch so thanks for this recipe. We will try it out. And the post was lovely too!
kelsey
Your connection to people long gone and the wonderful food stuffs they bestowed upon us
is something I've often thought about never quite got around to or articulated as well as you have here.....
And of course there's something not in the ingredients list that just seemed to make theirs a little better....
Thanks for the beans run-up. Looks good!
BEAUTIFUL photograph of you and your Grandma. Says it all. (Oh, and thanks for the recipe too!)
I actually signed up to comment on this post and have been puzzling over exactly what to say, without getting carried away, ever since.
I too have a taste-memory of such beans buried away which you have awoken; I'll enjoy giving your recipe a try. Raised in the South, my memories comes not from a Grandmother, but from a Creole "maid". (Images from "The Help" are appropriate...)
You've written an evocative piece; perhaps also a cautionary tale. It's ashamed that so often we do not understand the power of such connections and memories until it is years past "too late" to pass them along or to savor them in the moment.
Women are the primordial source of nourishment. They should honor themselves more so in that regard.
Such a wonderful photo--thanks so much for posting it. It just says it all.
I love stories like this of family recipes and how you've adapted to recreating them.
How would this work in a crock pot / slow cooker? It's too hot in my house to turn the oven on for 5+ hours.
Looks delicious! Might I be able to cook them in a crockpot instead? (I am new to slow cookery...)
Those asking about the crockpot - yes! Cook on low until the beans are tender. Bacon won't be crispy. You could also transfer to a casserole and finish in oven to crisp up the bacon and caramelize the top.
Sarah Kate, I just love your articles. Not only does this look absolutely delicious, but it's so wonderful to have a dish that brings up all sorts of memories. I totally get the same feeling whenever I make my grandma's Christmas cookies. Thanks for the lovely glimpse into your grandma's life and for sharing this recipe. Can't wait to try.
This is amazing. Not only is this dish absolutely scrumptious-sounding, but the bittersweet story is so relatable. I'll be trying this recipe soon.
POWERFUL MEMORY TRIGGER! Every time I eat a piece of gianduja, I think of my grandfather, who always brought a special box from Barton's just for me.
I can almost smell the beans just looking at the photo. YUM!
One question - I thought that the general rule of thumb was to discard the soaking liquid from beans? Something about them being less gas-inducing that way? Maybe that's just an urban kitchen myth. :o] Insight appreciated.
He ironic is it that I've been craving baked beans (I'm 6 months pregnant!) and I just so happened to find your post on the home page! Your recipe looks delicious!!!
Oops, I meant "how!" (darn auto-correct!!!)
This recipe looks like something an acquaintance used to make, but she added chopped green peppers. Also, she used several different types of beans, navy, pinto, kidney etc., all in the same dish. It was very good.
A beautiful tribute to your Grandma Kate! I felt the love in each word. I am going to make this delicious looking dish, soon. We are big bean eaters and I am always being asked to bring my bean dish to family functions. This will be exciting for me to try something new ..
Happy Holidays and thank you!
I screwed up! I drained the beans after soaking overnight. I now have no liquid to combine with my beans etc. Can I just add 6 cups of water to the beans or less? Does the water that I Threw away have a flavor from the soaked beans? I am 80 years old and maybe that's my excuse for not reading all the recipe ahead of time. I really need your advice so I can continue with the recipe. Lorraine. jlkaiser@shaw.ca.
Won't someone please reply to my question as asked above. I want to make this recipe today, so need to know how much water to add to this recipe as I drained my beans by mistake. Can I use a broth instead of water? Lorraine.
@Lorraine: i drained the beans too , so i added a little bit more of canned tomatoes and water to really cover the think. And it was ok and very good and it didn't burn. I guess beacause the fat in the bacon and the juice in the pineapples. Hope your dish was great too