Holiday parties are in full swing and New Years Eve (gasp) isn't all that far away. So it's time to break out the champagne! But wait: does that mean it's also time to shell out the big bucks?
Alex Halberstadt writes about the complex relationship between perceived quality and price of champagne on Gilt Taste. He says, "To nurture a desire for champagne is to make peace both with its singular pleasures--a kind of ecstatic brain freeze--and the inevitable expense." He calls it a "signifier of graceful living" but also points out how misunderstood it is and how often, especially with vintage bottles, people falsely equate cost with quality when really they may not understand how to tell when a good champagne is ready to be opened. For this reason, folks often let an expensive bottle sit far longer than it should.
There's a balance between saving a good bottle because it was pricey and knowing when to enjoy something now. Expensive doesn't always mean "save it for later." And inexpensive doesn't always mean expendable.
Elizabeth Apron fro...

I'd rather splurge on DeUs from Bosteels - if I can find it:
http://www.bestbelgianspecialbeers.be/main_eng.html
Nah. Just like any wine, what tastes good tastes good, no matter the price and usually that means more expensive is not better.
My favorite champagne of all time is 45 a bottle, but that doesn't mean I don't love a 7 dollar bottle of Prosecco or have a guilty pleasure for those 4 dollar bottles of Asti so popular for New Years!
I don't think price signifies quality per se, but the best wine I've ever tasted is Billecart-Salmon brut rose, which retails in my neighborhood for $80. It is worth every penny.
My criteria for what I would spend on champagne:
1. intimate gathering (i.e. small party, 4-5 ppl). I would splurge on the expensive stuff. And only if most of them like champagne. My favorite splurge is Nicolas Feuillatte Brut Non-Vintage Blue Label, runs ~$30. With fewer people, we're more likely to consume the champagne as it should be consumed and it's not sitting around for hours.
2. Big party, lots of ppl. I get the Asti. Because I like it. Most people I know who hate (or say they hate) champagne like it too. And it's not such a waste when it doesn't get consumed promptly.
It depends on how many people are drinking it. If its for a large party: Cristalino at $6 is the way to go. If its just my hubby and I or with another couple, then we'll splurge on something authentic.
My husband is all for expensive, French champagne, I'm usually happy with the cheaper but delicious German varieties or a good Prosecco or Cava.
As much as I love Veuve, it's not practical to buy regularly. I'm having a New Year's party and stocked up at Trader Joe's on inexpensive bubbly. We'll probably start with a relatively nicer bottle and move on down! But I do love Domaine Carneros brut as a mid-range option.
I'm the only one in my family and acquaintances that likes champagne/sparkling wine, so getting a regular size bottle is a waste, because I only ever drink one glass at a time. I'm afraid I end up buying whatever I can find in a split. I also like the Sofia sparkling wine that comes in the soda cans. Not the best, but drinkable and just the right size serving.
My husband will sometimes drink a mimosa with me, but why put the expensive stuff in a mimosa?
We do actually buy the good stuff for one annual party. Usually VC or Deutz if we can find it at a reasonable price or NF if we can't. We like some smaller houses as well but quanity is an issue.
Latkes and champagne are the perfect pairing. As we get older and we have kids as do a lot of our friends, people drink a lot less than in the past.
My husband and I both love champagne and many different but often expensive levels. Billecart Salmon Rose Cuvee Elizabeth is what I am hoping for at New Years.
And I disagree with Gilt's comment about aging. There is a fine and wonderful tradition of aging tradition in Britan and if you have the right kind of bottle it can benefit from it.
I usually don't splurge on champagne/sparkling wine. My husband always says he'll drink some with me, then leaves me with about 9/10ths of the bottle. We either opt for a smaller bottle or go cheap since I'm the only one who enjoys it.
I was introduced to wine by an older couple who were kind of surrogate grandparents. Their first rule of wine was that if they ever caught me paying more than $20 for a bottle, they'd never speak to me again, and one of them might well turn me over their knee for a spanking. (I've only broken that rule twice, and both times for Eiswein.) Since I don't care for dry bubbly, and expensive [demi-]sec is hard to find, I don't really have a lot of temptation.
I care more about tradition than price, and ever year for many I've splurged on a Tattinger Rose. It's just our thing for New Year's. I know there's better that's probably cheaper but it has sentimental value for us.
I know it's not quite champagne, but I'm a HUGE fan of Prosecco. It's cheap, lovely bubbly, and tastes great!
Being French, I enjoyed touring the champagne domains. We have a "family" address that we keep coming back to for ordinary champagne. It's about 12E for a Brut bottle bottle (less for greater quantities), and we used it at our wedding. Great for serving large crowds, and a very pleasing taste.
My personal favorite is Laurent Perrier extra-brut, but due to its price, it is reserved for very special occasions.
I didn't know they made vintage champagne bottles. I thought vintages were reserved to wines. Anyway, what's the point when you are supposed to drink them inside a year ? Champagne is also much less subject to yearly gaps in quality. Sounds like marketing to me, but I still learned something tonight.
I love an inexpensive prosecco, but I also really love Dom Perignon! If I am sharing it with a few friends, I will definitely go for a more expensive bottle.
Although I found myself to be so burnt out on the Veuve recently. The Moet Imperial is a nice change.
I really don't splurge on champagne, though I absolutely see the appeal! But I drink a lot of sparkling wine.
No, I mean, a lot of sparkling wine. It's my most frequent (alcoholic) drink these days, the wine I most often bring to a casual get-together, and the bottle I'm most likely to pop open just for myself on any given evening. I love having several bottles of inexpensive bubbly in the house so I don't hesitate to break it out for any reason --- or no reason.
monteig - if you enjoy DP, please think about trying Duval-Leroy's Femme (just had the 1995). It's about half the cost, and simply gorgeous! It has the nice lemon-y highlights, with great acidity and balance and a long, and very pleasing finish. It's about $150 a bottle, so a bargain compared to the DP.
I am a big fan of champagne and sparkling wines. And like Elsa Macbebekin, I keep several on hand and pop one open frequently.
The fact that I have no reason is reason enough to open a bottle and enjoy!
JudyAu: agreeing with you on Deutz being worth it. A bottle with some fish and chips will change your life.