The strong points:
• Easy to fill.
• Easy to select the grind of which there are five choices.
• The clear acrylic pepper storage area lets you know when you're running low.
• Sits with the blade side up, so pepper doesn't fall out.
• Good price point.
My quibbles are minor:
• The fine grind could be a little finer and the coarse could be a little coarser.
• I don't see much difference between the three grades of medium grind. OXO could have stayed with just fine - medium - coarse, instead of the five offered.
So why don't I love it?
This a very personal preference, but I'm not crazy about how it looks. Some people have described it as sleek and modern but it looks clunky to me. I feel the same way about stainless steel appliances, which the OXO kind of reminds me of, so there you go.
This mill performs well and has enough going for it that I'm fine with having it in the kitchen. But it doesn't make me smile when I reach for it, it doesn't somehow fit my life. Sigh. I know I'm asking too much of a mere pepper mill but this is a tool I use everyday, sometimes several times a day. This is something I grab and put on my dining room table when I have friends over for dinner. I suspect the OXO won't be my last pepper mill. My search continues.
• Find it: OXO Good Grips Pepper Grinder, $17.38 at Amazon