It's been a little nippy in San Francisco recently, and I started craving one of my favorite comfort foods: shepherd's pie. Or cottage pie to you readers in Australia and the UK. This meat and vegetable pie with mashed potato crust is very humble and simple, but very economical, filling, and delicious.
Some notes about the filling. It's more traditional for shepherd's pie in the US to have a beef filling whereas the British and Australians are more likely to use lamb. You could also try ground turkey for a lower fat alternative, or your favorite soy crumbles if you are a vegetarian. You could use fresh vegetables, but I prefer to use frozen vegetables as it saves me the chopping and peeling time, and since I already have the ground beef and the vegetables in my freezer, that means I don't have to go out and shop for anything.
Since it's just me and my boyfriend, I divide this recipe in three batches; two go in the freezer in my favorite Pyrex storage containers, and one is cooked and eaten right away. This way we aren't eating leftovers all week, as this recipe is family-sized.
For a switch-up, try adding some boiled rutabaga or parsnips to your mashed potatoes. They're yummy. This recipe from Simply Recipes is one of our favorites:
• Easy Shepherd's Pie from Simply Recipes
(Image: Kathryn Hill)
How To Cook Fluffy, Tasty Quinoa
Perfect Summer Cocktail Recipe: Honey Bourbon Lemonade
Good Food to Share 
The Big Book of Small, Cool Spaces 
Apartment Therapy Presents 
The Eight-Step Home Cure 
Elizabeth Apron fro...
100 DIY Ideas for the 3-Day Weekend
Danielle's Charming, Classic Walk-Up
In the UK and Ireland it's Shepard's Pie if it contains lamb (often left overs from a Sunday roast) and Cottage Pie if beef is used.
In Québécois, it's "Pâté chinois", or Chinese pie.
No idea why.
Mmm. I made a vegetarian version last week with carrots, onions, peas, mushrooms, broccoli and kale. It was delicious!
Is adding cheese to the top NOT traditional? My Irish husband would be very disappointed if the cheese were left out... (Not that we go all traditional--I like to top mine with a mix of regular and sweet potatoes!)
The "pâté chinois" chinois of Québec is usually made with ground beef and the layer of vegetables is canned corn. And it may be unorthodox, but I like to add a bit of cheeese on top too. Now, I feel like making it.
I love shepard's pie! i made 2 batches last week and froze the leftovers. I cant wait to eat them. I followed the recipe from the Tea & Sympahty cookbook (the NYC Brit teashop). It was great, they add tomato juice to the meat (i used lamb) which made it saucy... perfection! Here's the recipe: http://337greenwich.blogspot.com/2009/09/i-britain-minced-lamb-shepards-pie.html
Just made shepherd's pie last week too. :D Great minds must be thinking alike. I put down my meat mixture, then a layer of grated cheddar before putting the potatoes on top. Yum.
mmm... a favorite of mine! An Italian version with sweet or spicy Italian sausage and added oregano and garlic is yummy too!
Love shepherd's pie. I like to fry a few strips of bacon and crumble them in the top of the filling before I lay the mashed taters, then sprinkle the top of the taters with some breadcrumbs (don't know why, I like the toast flavor along with the taters...)
Oh and I sometimes use chunks of chicken breast instead of beef or ground turkey. It's kind of like chicken pot shep's pie or something like that. I do prefer using fresh veggies to frozen (with the exception of peas) - I find frozen veggies have this strange taste and texture...
I really enjoy Michael Chiarello's recipe, available on the Food Network site. It's a little elaborate for a traditionally humble dish like Shepherd's Pie, but it's definitely a delicious spin.
I like to sprinkle the top with aged white cheddar near the end of cooking. It really makes it.
I would add red wine (whatever you have on hand) and a little tomato paste/puree to this recipe. Just adds a great depth of flavor to the beef. Also, sprinkling the top with parmesan...saw Gordon Ramsay make it with these variations on the F Word and I couldn't wait to try it out. Made it sooo much better.
bridmw took the words right out of my mouth! Same in Aus I believe - Shepherd's is lamb, Cottage is beef.
I have a recipe for "Shepherdess Pie", which has beef in for some reason (I guess the book was just looking for a cute name), but is good:
Fry an onion, add 1/2kilo / 1lb of minced/ground beef, fry til browned. Then add some chopped up rosemary to taste, a 400g/1lb tin of chopped tomatoes, a broken up beef OXO cube (only time I use them!) or similar beef-stock-flavour-depth-giver, season, and cook for a few minutes. Put it into an ovenproof casserole (or just do those first stages in something like a Le Creuset), top with mashed together potato and carrot, use a fork to ridge it all a bit so you get crispy bits and cook at about 180C/350F for 20-30mins, until the top is how you like it.
I also love doing a 'normal' cottage or shepherd's pie with extra veggies like peas in, and grated cheese on top. Yum.
When I was growing up we had "Hamburger Pie" - likely a 50s version of "Shepherds Pie":
Sautee chopped onions. Add ground beef and brown. Mix in one can of Campbell's tomato soup. Pour into bottom of casserole dish. Top with layer of canned green beans and then a layer of mashed potatoes. Cover with grated cheddar cheese. Bake at 350° F until cheese melts (my mom did it until the cheese got a little browned on the edges - my favorite part).
My brother and I loved this dish, but realizing that the families that I nannied for would probably not appreciate a casserole made with Campbell's soup and canned vegetables, I made a slightly fresher version. I subbed either chopped tomatoes or tomato sauce and a bit of red wine and herbs (cooked down a bit for thickness) for the soup and used fresh green beans. It's now one of my husband's favorite winter dishes (even if he refers to it as "WT Pie"
Shepherd's pie is one of my favorites! I make it at least a couple times a month in the winter.
I also love to make "Thanksgiving Shepherd's Pie," which was an improvisation that turned out to be a huge hit. Ground turkey (cooked with sage and rosemary) and veggies on the bottom, an optional layer of cornbread stuffing in the middle, and sweet potatoes on top -- served with cranberry sauce, of course. Yum!
Brooklynnina, I am with you, where is the layer of cheese across the top??
I bet that brown lentils would make a tasty substitute for ground meat...!