Apparently black is the new pale, because we’ve been noticing a rise of India pale ales that are anything but. These IPAs are as dark as stouts, but with the hefty hop kick of, well, an IPA. Honestly, we can’t decide how we feel about this one.
IPAs traditionally use pale, lightly roasted malts - hence the “pale” in both the name and the color. Black IPAs keep everything the same, but substitute the kind of roasted malts used for darker beers like porters and bock lagers. The result is an aromatic, hoppy beer with an undercurrent of dark roastiness.
That is, when it’s done well. We’ve had some black IPAs where the malt character was still so understated that the beer seemed more like a trompe d’oiel - close your eyes and you would think it was a regular IPA. We’ve had others where the citrusy bitterness of the hops just seemed to clash with the dark chocolate and coffee-like bitterness of the malts.
So far, we haven’t had a really good one that a) made us excited about finishing the glass or b) presented itself as a distinct style and not just a hopped up porter or stout. There are some black IPAs out there getting good reviews:
• Sublimely Self-Righteous Ale from Stone Brewing Company
• DogZilla Black IPA from Laughing Dog Brewery
• W’10 Pitch Black IPA from Widmer Brothers Brewing Company
We’ll keep our eye out for these and see if they revise our opinion of this potentially new style.
Have you tried any black IPAs?
Related: Quick and Dirty Guide to American Beer Styles
(Image: Flickr member SarahMcD licensed under Creative Commons)
How To Cook Fluffy, Tasty Quinoa
True Greek Recipe: Paximadi Bread Salad with Tomatoes, Feta and Capers
Good Food to Share 
The Big Book of Small, Cool Spaces 
Apartment Therapy Presents 
The Eight-Step Home Cure 
Monterey Pitcher fr...
Before & After: Emily Henderson Transforms a Senior's Studio Space
Monica & Austin's Charming Bungalow
I have a bomber of Sublimely Self Righteous I should drink soon. Almost forgot about it.
I really enjoyed the Dogzilla from Laughing Dog. The Hop in the Dark from Deschutes is another good choice.
I prefer darker beers, and I also like hoppier, more bitter beers. So I might actually like this combo.
Only if it actually adds to the beer, however. If it's just a gimmick, then don't bother (like some of the black lagers I've had, particularly Saranac's)
I like the Self-Righteous from Stone, but I didn't care for the 21st Amendment Black IPA.
It's not necessarily my favorite style, but I have a small sample size. I greatly prefer Imperial Stouts, IPAs and Imperial IPAs.
I trust Stone Brewery pretty much implicitly. I'll definitely check out the SSRA!
Southern Tier Iniquity is really good!
I'm confused. How can it be "pale" if it is like a stout?
<3 I am a total HOP head!! and I love everything by Laughing Dog brewery!! I am a fan of the dark IPA's because I get that amazing mouth feel and great roasted notes as well as lots of hops.
1554--a black ale from New Belgium is delightful. Its dark, but not heavy so it doesn't taste like a hopped up stout or porter. However it is not an IPA, so the hoppiness is a little more subdued. Its the perfect combo of malt and hop.
I have a batch of Black IPA homebrew that I made recently (extract kit purchased at Northern Brewer here in Minneapolis). I'm waiting for it to not taste like hoppy molasses. It's smoothing out some, but still.