We've been testing the Star for a few weeks and comparing it to our current favorite from Oxo ...
Ades sells his Star peeler on the street for $5, the Oxo peelers start around $6. The Star has a minimalist design and stainless steel shine. While Oxo gives us the Aeron chair of peelers, the Star has its own mid-century function driven flair.
We found that we had to change the motion we use to peel to get the most out of the Star. Holding the Star parallel to the body using a left-to-right or right-to-left motion, like Ades uses in his demonstrations, works best.
The Star has a metal hook on the side that makes digging eyes out of potatoes easy. Ades uses the hook to create carrot flowers and three sided french fries.
Because the Star doesn't have a padded handle, the cook feels more control over the thickness of the peels. If you want a peeler to quickly cut long stands of carrot for a slaw or salad, that could be the tool for you. We got tired faster when using the Star, so will still reach for our champ -- the Oxo -- when facing a ten pound bag of potatoes.