Milk and Booze! How To Make Sweet Milk Liqueur

Say hello to the newest addition to our liquor cabinet! This rather improbable combination of vodka and milk makes a liqueur so smooth and perfectly sweet that you'll want to sip it straight. Get the recipe, our review, and some ideas for using this sweet liqueur below.

Pin it button big

We love the idea of making our own liqueurs, and we've been wanting to try this milk liqueur ever since we saw it in David Leite's most recent book The New Portuguese Table. Simply made by mixing vodka or grappa with an equal amount of milk and sugar, it just seemed so unusual and fascinating.

The hardest part about this liqueur is waiting for it to infuse. It needs ten days in a dark corner of your kitchen, where the vodka slowly turns from clear to bright yellow. Be warned: it looks completely disgusting. The milk coagulates and separates when mixed with the vodka, looking more like a science experiment gone wrong than anything you'll ever want to serve your dinner guests.

But strained a few times to catch all those milk solids, the resulting liqueur is perfectly clear with a lovely sunshine yellow hue. It smells like a mixture of ice cream and malted milk balls. The liqueur has a smooth and syrupy mouthfeel and a rich creamy flavor. It's sweet, but with a more complex flavor than simple sugar: malty and slightly caramelized.

This is definitely a winner in our book. We can't wait to make another batch and try a few different flavor variations.

Ideas for Using:
Split into several small bottles for presents - Wouldn't these make a cute Valentine's day gift?
Drink it neat - We really like sipping a finger of this liqueur as is before bedtime. An adult version of a warm glass of milk, you might say!
Mixed into cocktails - The sweet flavors of this liqueur go very well with bourbon and rum.

Pin it button big
Homemade Milk Liqueur

adapted from The New Portuguese Table by David Leite

Makes about 1 quart of liqueur

2 cups vodka
2 cups whole or 2% milk (non-UHT pasteurized for best results*)
2 cups granulated sugar
1/2 (or more) of lemon or other citrus, juice and rind**

Mix everything together in a clean glass container with a tight-sealing lid. Shake vigorously and store in a cool, dark place for 10 days. Give the container a few shakes every day.

After 10 days, the liqueur is ready. Strain through a double-layer of cheese cloth or a coffee filter to catch the milk solids and clarify the liqueur. More rounds of straining will result in a cleaner, clearer liqueur.

Transfer to a clean container and store for up to several months.

Variations:
Chocolate Milk Liqueur - David Leite's original recipe in The New Portuguese Table calls for two ounces of dark chocolate and half a lemon. We imagine this would add even more malty undertones to the liqueur.
Orange Milk Liqueur - Try adding one or two whole chopped oranges and one whole chopped lemon. This gives the liqueur a wonderful citrus blossom perfume and flavor.
Chai Milk Liqueur - Infuse the milk and vodka with a classic chai blend of cinnamon, fennel seed, cardamom, coriander, cloves, and fresh ginger. You could even add a scoop of black tea!
Brown Sugar Milk Liqueur - We're extremely curious how the darker flavor of brown sugar might change the flavor of the liqueur!
Fresh Fruit Milk Liqueur - Strawberry milk liqueur, anyone? Raspberries and cream? Oh, we can't wait for summer.

* The milk liqueur may not coagulate as readily when using UHT pasteurized milk. If using, increase the amount of citrus.
** A small amount of citrus will help the milk to coagulate. Adding more citrus will give a more pronounced citrusy flavor.

Updated 1/24/12

(Images: Emma Christensen)

Per serving, based on 2 servings. (% daily value)
Calories
1409
Fat
4.8 g (7.4%)
Saturated
3 g (15.2%)
Trans
0.2 g
Carbs
211.7 g (70.6%)
Sugars
211.9 g
Protein
8.1 g (16.1%)
Cholesterol
19.5 mg (6.5%)
Sodium
118.9 mg (5%)

93 Comments