This past Easter weekend, in addition to my tropical fruit salad, I also made these S'Mores Cakes in jars. (A good balance of healthy and totally not right? Right!) After baking up a batch I learned several things about the current desserts in jars trend. I decided that once you've made a dessert in a jar, all other desserts officially feel overrated. Here's why!
First of all, Jessica from How Sweet It Is deserves mad props for this recipe. Although I've seen many (like whoa) recipes in jars lately, most of them involved frosting of some sort. Ultimately this means two things. The first is that most likely your dessert should probably be refrigerated and can be harmed by sitting in the sun for a few hours if say, you're at a picnic. The next is that instead of making a quick cake, you're also washing dishes and dirtying them again by making frosting.
• Get the recipe: S'mores Cake In A Jar at How Sweet It Is
Instead this recipe uses marshmallows that get placed on the cake just after it's baked. They are popped back in the oven for a few moments to brown the tops and make them look all pretty, like they just strolled out of a summer campfire. Awesome right? Totally.
When I made this dessert I fell hook line and sinker for this method. Here's what I learned and why I think desserts in jars are the bee's knees:
1. Zero Refrigeration Required: I took these desserts to a friend's house and they made the trip there without any icing getting goey or having things shift during transport. Even better, the remaining jars sat on my countertop for the next several days (and still are) without any worry of spoiling. If you wanted to use a "real" icing instead of marshmallow, you could always apply it just before eating so there's no worry.
2. Individual or Family Style: If you make cakes or cupcakes in a jar each person has something to hold and your jars will always get used down the line (unlike paper plates which just get thrown away). You can also make them in larger jars to eat a dessert family-style and have it be passed around. I made mine in quart jars and it would have been perfect to toss into a picnic basket to munch on outside or even on the go — road trip friendly desserts? Absolutely!
3. They Get Better With Time: There aren't many desserts that get better after a few days. Though truth be told, most desserts don't last a few days in our kitchen, but that's besides the point. You can add a lid to each dessert and the small amount of humidity inside makes each cake a little more moist and slightly more dense and rich. It sounds silly, but come day 3 you'll want to bathe in them. What? That's weird. Um, never mind. Moving on.
4. They Can Be Carried Without Breakage: We dedicate a great deal of time to snacks and desserts that are work friendly. Why? Because no one wants their cookie all crumbled or cake crumbs in the bottom of their bag by the time they arrive. Although you will have the weight of the jar (big whoop), it will arrive safely each and every time no matter what and no matter how it's carried. Sealed... just waiting for you to take the first bite — which may or may not be before lunch time!
5. Mason Jars Are Easier To Store: I have a passion for baked goods and am always whipping something up in my kitchen. They look pretty displayed under a glass dome or on a cake pedestal on the counter, but cake plates and their covers are one of the biggest space hogs in the kitchen. Forget them completely and just keep some canning jars on hand. Simple. Done!
Have you tried making desserts in jars yet? Did you love the experience as much as I did? Share your thoughts in the comments below!
Related: Great Bake Sale Idea: Cobbler in a Jar from Not Martha
(Image: How Sweet It Is)

Comments (33)
Mason jars are pretty!
Also, in more practical terms, they don't leak when turned upside-down in a purse (oh say), which makes them perfect for transporting lunches (or breakfasts!).
Layered yogurt parfaits in 250ml jars with fresh fruit? Gorgeous dessert OR breakfast, and the layers just make the colors prettier!
I hate them, let me count the ways (or wizz-ays, or wizzy dizzies, if you prefer):
1 - the jars just make dessert just that much more heavy to lug around. Individually this isn't a problem. Collectively, that's a lot of heavy glass. Carrying a dozen jars is not a very public-transit friendly way of bringing treats to the office or school or whathaveyou.
2 - instead of one cake container in my fridge, i've got a bunch of little breakable glass jars all over the place, taking up space.
3 - portion control. Sure i could stick the lid back on the half-eaten jar of cake and eat it later, but you know what would be better? Cutting a smaller slice of cake and eating the whole thing. It is harder to judge how much has been eaten from a jar ... maybe a cup of cake? Who knows!
4 - having to dig my way through whatever frostingy stuff has been stuck on the top. Things with layers should be served in a form that allows for sideways access to actually appreciate all the layers at once.
5 - They make me feel like i'm eating a wedding reception favour or something. Actually a dessert in a jar might be a nice wedding reception favour, so i'll withhold my hate in that care (but ONLY in that case).
Kittystockings - You could always use babyfood jars (they're on Craigslist all the time) to make lugging them around easier!
Geez, I don't want anything sitting out on my counter for a few days!
well, i'll try anything that's "the schizzle-dizzle" once.
All I cant think of are all these nooks and crannies to wash.... Meh. I just don't get that trend. Also less breakage while using glass containers? C'mon. You need a better argument than that. As for the storing... they take way more place than rectangular/square, stackable containers (be them in plastic or glass).I'll pass this one and wait for a more appealing trend.
Eh. I'm on the fence on this one. Wide-mouthed small jars with a little pie in them? YES! A full-size Mason jar with layers of s'mores? I'm sorry, that just does NOT look appealing to me at all. I don't like digging down through layer one to layer two (as mentioned above). And carrying glass being no big whoop? You don't use public transit in NYC do you? It's a whoop. It can be done, sure, but it does come with a whoop factor.
This thanksgiving, I made POD (Pie On Demand; individual pies baked in 4 oz jelly jars.) I hadn't anticipated this backfiring on me...until my ten-year-old son came into the kitchen a few days later and said "Mom - I demand - Pie!" (stinker!)
i think they look like good party favors but not much more than that. sorry
Nope. Not the least bit "shizzle", or whatever stupid phrase you want to call it. Jars are heavy, take up more room than one cake or several stackable pans, and are NOT less breakable. Pass on this trend as well.
On the "breakable" issue--one of the reasons my mom used pint canning jars for drinking glasses when we were kids is that they are super rugged. I use them for lunches and recently dropped one on the tile floor at work. Oopsie! But, it bounced, so no harm done.
And, just because it's a pint or a half pint or whatever does not mean you have to fill it completely. Does that even need to be pointed out?
Yeah, real canning jars can take a hell of a lot of abuse. They're made to last decades. (Some of my mom's jars are, in fact, much older than I am!)
For desserts in jars, though, I'd probably stick to the smaller, wide mouth jars. Love the idea of S'more cake. :)
I too am skeptical about the mason jar trend. Maybe in smaller widemouth jars, this would be good, but a pint sized jar of cake is too much, even for greedy ol me. I would however like to do these in 8-10ounce ramekins. The recipe sounds delicious...
What makes you think putting something in a jar magically makes it not require refrigeration?
This is a stupid gimmick and your arguments in favor of it are not at all convincing.
kittystockings, you made me smile.
Couldn't this be made in a large 9x13 pan?
kittystockings, thank you for your counter-arguments!! I agree with them all!
Especially the part about digging through the heap sticky sweetness at the top to get proportionate bites of whatever is layered through the rest of the dessert.
This is no different than the stupid "stacked" trend my (bad cook) sister tried to force on us. Except in a jar.
I know most Americans are piglets these days but seriously, does anyone need this much dessert?
Add one more vote to the dissent: food in jars is a boring trend.
I think they are perfect and adorable for gift giving, but I don't really understand their function in other situations.
<insert desert here> in a jar...
underwhelmed.
uh... *dessert* duh!
Hmm, I wonder if some of the discontent comes from folks who don't have a lot of experience with canning jars? As one commenter said, they ARE very sturdy, about the least breakable glass you can imagine. They also go from freezer to fridge to table to workbag to oven . . . don't leak when sealed, and are available in quart, pint, and several smaller (really cute and useful) sizes, all the way down to a petite half-size jelly jar.
So I guess I feel the opposite from most of those posters -- I'm up for just about anything in a canning jar, not just dessert! They've become the workhorses of my kitchen. Try them!
Another "no"...it might work as a party gimmick but pretty impractical. And you'd need a long spoon to reach the bottom.
As someone who recently dropped a box of Mason jars down a flight of stairs, I disagree with the claim that they are super-durable.
I have seen verrines in jars that were kind of charming, but you have to find a certain kind of jar (small, yet wide) and be very neat with the layering.
@pinky41 -- mason jars are workhorses in my kitchen too (and I would guess many people here know their way around canning equipment just fine regardless of how they feel about this idea).
I just found this one particular approach to mason jars completely unappealing. And I have a major soft spot for mason jars of all shapes, sizes, and vintages so even with a large selection of them down in my basement, this idea simply doesn't resonate with me.
Well said, pinky41! I'm a mason jar lover and use them for absolutely everything.
I love mini cakes and pies in jars, because there are only two people in my house. Easy to make and freeze, then bake or reheat as desired.
I also love storing, serving, and transporting stuff in my mason jars, because they ARE so sturdy. I even use them as glasses, and to take food to work. (I just toss them in my bag, and they survive public transit fine.) Less plastic is a good thing.
But I don't think I'd be baking anything that large, dessert-wise. Small, 8-ounce wide mouths or half cups are what I like! Intriguing recipe, though, for variety.
Why is everyone so damn grumpy?
I'm about to jump through my computer to eat that thing!
Logistically, anything in a tall container is a nightmare to eat. I want to taste each layer together. Impossible to do without a long spoon, and even then it's a mess. I eat yogurt, fruit and granola for breakfast, but only in a cereal bowl. No parfait dishes for me, thanks.
Being an ex-NYer I can see folks not wanting to schlepp a whole bunch of jars on the subway, bus, etc. But I also think that in the right situation deserts in a jar sound pretty great. You can always get smaller jars. You can use long iced-tea spoons. And for taking to an outdoor, picnic type event it certainly sounds like a great way to minimize all sorts of waste (paper plates, etc.), and needing to cut and serve. I think these have their place in life!
How very silly. Another daft fashion that will be mocked in years to come. There was a fad for chicken served in a basket in the UK some years ago. It became extraordinarily popular, although whether it had been served in a basket, a mop bucket or Cleopatra's navel the food was just as bad as it always had been.
Get a grip, people!
Man, so many jar haters! We made the smore's in a jar a couple months ago and they were PERFECT!! If you're worried about portion control, you can use smaller jars. They're very rich so I didn't finish all of mine...I just put the lid back on. Easy peasy!
Though they're in glass jars, they're definitely easier to transport than a cake carrier. Cake carries have to be kept upright or else you'll ruin the cake if someone bumps you on the train or it slides around in the car. With the jars, you can throw them in a bag (they're not that heavy if you're making less than a dozen pints or 24 smaller.) and they can turn any which way and it won't matter. Perfect! We actually made a smores cake yesterday for my husband's work and he had the hardest time trying to keep it from getting ruined on the commute this morning. Not good!
Oh, and as for having to dig through layers, you can again use the smaller jars or use sundae/iced tea spoons like we did. They're long enough that you can dig through the marshmallows with no problem!
As A2Z said, they're great for picnics and parties, plus they're reusable!
Can't wait to make them again :)